Inorganic nitrate supplementation and exercise. Is skeletal muscle involved in the heavy lifting?
Nitric oxide (NO) is a lipid soluble, diatomic gas that affects a plethora of biological functions from immune defence and neurotransmission to blood flow regulation and skeletal muscle force production. The ubiquity of NO and its short half-life necessitates that the right concentration, at the right time, in a specific location, may mediate physiological outcomes. The article by Wylie and colleagues in this issue of The Journal of Physiology (Wylie et al. 2019) explores the potential that skeletal muscle could serve as a reservoir of nitrogen oxides (nitrate and nitrite), which, under certain physiological circumstances, could be transported between tissues and converted to NO. It combines the expertise of Piknova and Schechter (National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK), USA) in NO signalling and muscle biology with that of the University of Exeter (UK) group in exercise science and inorganic nitrate supplementation. These human subject data demonstrate, under resting conditions, a concentration gradient of nitrate and nitrite from skeletal muscle tissue to the vascular compartment. Previous work using nNOS−/− rodents attributed this gradient to skeletal muscle neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) production of NO and subsequent oxidation (Piknova et al. 2015). The presence of nNOS protein expression in this human study adds credence to this conclusion. Following oral inorganic nitrate supplementation (12.8 mmol), large increases in plasma nitrate (and nitrite) were accompanied by elevated skeletal muscle nitrate (∼900–1000 nmol g−1). This complements earlier murine data which revealed liver tissue nitrate concentrations to be lower than in the plasma, suggesting a potential transport gradient between the compartments (Piknova et al. 2015). Furthermore, a 6.5 min bout of high intensity exercise significantly reduced skeletal muscle nitrate while plasma levels remained constant. Previous human exercise studies have shown both reductions and no changes in plasma nitrite and nitrate following exercise stress of various intensities and/or durations in subjects with a wide variety of health status. Given the multiple ways NO has been implicated in mediating mitochondrial function, skeletal muscle contractile efficiency and tissue perfusion/oxygenation during exercise, the idea that skeletal muscle could act as a nitrogen oxide reservoir that can be sequestered to maintain circulating levels of nitrate and nitrite for distribution is provocative. Evidence of the presence of sialin, an active nitrate transporter, in skeletal muscle provides a potential mechanism by which this skeletal muscle nitrate loading could occur and strengthens this hypothesis. This finding likely needs further confirmation given the variability in sialin expression between subjects, and a lack of relative control tissues for comparison (although the ubiquity of sialin and the required extra tissue sampling in this human study makes the latter difficult). A second possibility for storing and releasing NO when needed is intra-compartment oxidation and reduction. NO can be converted to nitrite and nitrate in an oxidative environment and in the presence of oxymyoglobin (oxy-Mb). Conversely, nitrate can be reduced to nitrite via oral bacteria and potentially xanthine oxidoreductase (XOR). Nitrite in turn is easily reduced to NO via a variety of pathways including protons, deoxymyoglobin (deoxy-Mb) and XOR, which may be facilitated in a low environment. Previously, the authors have shown an upregulation of XOR (and sialin) in Mb−/− mice suggesting it may be a compensatory mechanism to maintain skeletal muscle nitrogen oxide homeostasis (Park et al. 2019). In the current paper, they present evidence of XOR expression in human skeletal muscle tissue. During high intensity exercise, the relative reduction in both and pH would favour nitrite reduction to NO and theoretically XOR-mediated reduction of nitrate to nitrite. They previously demonstrated a decrease in rodent skeletal nitrate, accompanied by an increase in nitrite after a single bout of exercise (Piknova et al. 2016). Conversely, they also showed that despite expression of XOR in rat skeletal muscle there was no production of nitrite with increasing dosages of nitrate or 24 h of incubation (Piknova et al. 2015). It would appear that the possibility of nitrate to nitrite conversion by XOR in skeletal muscle is feasible; however, the amounts of XOR protein expression compared to tissues such as the liver is extremely low. In the current paper, there was a large between-subject variability in skeletal muscle XOR protein expression and no XOR relative-tissue controls to quantify the amounts. How much XOR in the skeletal muscle is needed to play a significant role in nitrogen oxide signalling is unknown but given 30–40% of a healthy person's body mass is muscle, even low concentrations of XOR could potentially play a significant role. In the last 10 years, there has been increased interest in the role of inorganic nitrate supplementation to enhance exercise performance. In healthy human studies the results are mixed with meta-analyses reporting overall no benefit for maximal graded exercise and time trial performance testing, but likely a benefit in time to exhaustion tests. A beneficial effect also appears more likely following chronic dosing regimens in less conditioned individuals (including those with cardiovascular impairments) employing higher intensity activities which utilize fast twitch muscle fibres (Woessner et al. 2018). In the current study a single dose of inorganic nitrate was used in 13 healthy, relatively fit subjects ( ∼50 ml kg−1 min−1) which could partially explain a lack of changes in time to task failure, despite high intensity activity being utilized. In the supplemented condition, there was a substantial decrease in skeletal muscle nitrate (∼700 nmol g−1) and plasma nitrite decreased by ∼0.2 nmol g−1. The lack of ergogenic effect, however, makes it difficult to speculate on what these changes mean. More may not always be better. Perhaps the right concentration, at the right time, in the right location is the key to physiological and physical benefits? Given the plethora of studies connecting vascular NO bioavailability with markers of vascular health such as blood pressure and endothelial function, further exploration of this topic is clearly warranted. This paper, and previous work by these investigators, presents thought-provoking data that will stimulate exploration to clarify the mechanisms underpinning intra- and inter-compartmental nitrogen oxide chemistry and resultant physiological outcomes, such as cardiovascular health and exercise in larger more heterogeneous groups of subjects. None declared. Both authors have approved the final version of the manuscript and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved. All persons designated as authors qualify for authorship, and all those who qualify for authorship are listed. None.
Read more