European Melody, African Rhythm, or West Indian Harmony? Changing Cultural Identity Among Leaders in a New State
We compare a re-study of the cultural identities of 83 leaders in 1974, twelve years after Jamaica's political independence, with a study completed just before independence in 1962. With a largely slave-descendant, black population, Jamaica has a mixed Creole culture with Anglo-European and African features combined with local modifications and innovations. Historically, cultural domination followed political domination, and the Anglo culturalfeatures were most influential and positively correlated with social class. Over the last several years, however, the African elements have been asserted by a number of groups, including Black Power advocates. From 1962 to 1974, Jamaican leaders became dramatically less Anglo-European and more West Indian in their cultural identities. Also, a smaller increase in favorable attitudes toward the African heritage may have occurred among the leaders. In 1962, West Indian identified leaders were younger; light brown or medium brown in skin color; less well educated; political or labor leaders; relatively not wealthy; and favorably disposed toward political democracy, political independence, a large role of the state in the economy, and social equality. In 1974, only age maintained its correlation; others were smaller. Path models were constructed explaining 55 percent of the variance in West Indian cultural identity and 57 percent in attitudes toward the African heritage in 1962, but only 12 and 11 *We gratefully acknowledge financial assistance from the National Institute of Mental Health (Grant No. 5-TO1-MH12133) that supported the Yale Comparative Sociology Training Program, of which this study is part; from the Concilium on International and Area Studies, Yale University; and the American Philosophical Society for a small grant to the first author (Penrose Fund, Grant No. 7454). We also thank our colleagues Juan J. Baldrich, J. William Gibson, Jr., and David L. Stevenson for their important contributions, including some of the interviewing of Jamaican leaders. Finally, we thank Professor Charles C. Moskos, Jr., Northwestern University, who kindly made his 1961-62 data available to us; Jamaican Vernon L. Arnett who gave us advice throughout the project; and Leonard W Doob and Carol S. Holzberg who made comments on a preliminary draft. This is a revised version of a paper we gave at the annual meeting of the International Studies Association, 1977. C) 1979, University of North Carolina Press. 0037-7732/79/010249-79$03.10
Read more