Selecting the optimal battery for a 10-inch FPV drone in civil missions: analysis of energy efficiency and autonomy (comparison of Molicel P42A 6S2P/3P/4P and LiPo 6S 10Ah)
The study focuses on the analysis and optimization of energy supply systems for unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), specifically FPV drones equipped with 10-inch propellers, to increase flight duration and operational efficiency under various civilian application scenarios. With the rapid expansion of drone usage in fields such as agriculture, environmental monitoring, logistics, and technical inspection, the issue of selecting the most efficient power source has become particularly relevant. The research aims to determine the optimal type of battery in terms of weight, energy density, endurance, and cost-effectiveness, ensuring reliable operation and sufficient energy reserve for different mission profiles. The article presents a comparative analysis between a lithium-polymer (LiPo) battery pack (6S, 10Ah) and three lithium-ion (Li-Ion) battery assemblies based on Molicel P42A cells with different configurations: 6S2P, 6S3P, and 6S4P. The analysis includes both theoretical calculations and practical considerations derived from known empirical data. Each configuration was evaluated based on three main criteria – flight time, maximum range, and overall economic viability. Additionally, the influence of payload mass (0–3 kg) on flight duration and efficiency was modeled for six key mission scenarios: observation and video surveillance, light and medium cargo delivery, heavy cargo delivery, one-way missions, and high-speed flight operations. Methodologically, the work takes into account motor efficiency (0.8–0.85), aerodynamic drag, and the voltage behavior of both LiPo and Li-Ion systems under load. The results demonstrate that Li-Ion batteries offer a higher specific energy density (up to 180 Wh/kg) and lower cost per watt-hour compared to LiPo alternatives, though their discharge characteristics limit maximum current output. Among the tested configurations, the Li-Ion 6S3P assembly showed the most balanced performance, providing a flight time of up to 45 minutes without payload and maintaining stable voltage throughout the discharge cycle. The LiPo 6S 10Ah pack remains advantageous for high-current, short-duration missions such as racing or rapid-response operations due to its superior instantaneous power output. The study concludes that no single battery configuration is universally optimal for all use cases. However, the Li-Ion 6S3P pack can be considered the most versatile and practical solution for multi-purpose civilian FPV platforms, combining reasonable cost, low weight, and extended endurance. The article also provides recommendations for selecting power systems depending on the mission profile and discusses the practical aspects of battery assembly, including the use of bi-metal copper and nickel-plated steel strips (0.15×10 mm) to ensure low resistance and reliable current transfer during high-load operation. The findings highlight the need for further experimental validation under real-world flight conditions, as well as future research focused on optimizing propeller geometry, assessing temperature impacts, and integrating hybrid power systems for small UAVs. The proposed analytical framework and results can serve as a methodological foundation for engineers, drone developers, and energy system designers seeking to enhance the performance and energy efficiency of modern FPV drones
Read more