- Research Article
62
- 10.1016/s0377-2217(01)00318-6
Output–input ratio analysis and DEA frontier
- Nov 01, 2002
- European Journal of Operational Research
- Yao Chen + 1 more +1
Output–input ratio analysis and DEA frontier
Data envelopment analysis (DEA), based on mathematical programming techniques, is a popular method for assessing the relative efficiency of various decision-making units (DMUs). Efficient DEA computations need to circumvent intensive time-consuming calculations. This paper indicates that the “corner points” in single input and single output scatter plot has extreme efficiency with regard to the multiple input and multiple output DEA models. This finding allows us to use two-way scatter plots to identify a subset of efficient DMUs prior to the DEA computations. These efficiency units provide a good heuristic solution to DEA without solving DEA mathematical programs. A simulated data set consisting of twenty R&D projects is presented to illustrate this technique’s effectiveness and efficiency.
Output–input ratio analysis and DEA frontier
Output–input ratio analysis and DEA frontier
DEA efficiency analysis: A DEA approach with double frontiers
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) is a method for measuring efficiency of peer decision-making units (DMUs). Conventional DEA evaluates the performance of each DMU using a set of most favourable weights. As a result, traditional DEA models can be considered methods for the analysis of the best relative efficiency or analysis of the optimistic efficiency. DEA efficient DMUs obtained from conventional DEA models create an efficient production frontier. Traditional DEA can be used to identify units with good performance in the most desirable scenarios. There is a similar approach that evaluates the performance indicators of each DMU using a set of most unfavourable weights. Accordingly, such models can be considered models for analysing the worst relative efficiency or pessimistic efficiency. This approach uses the inefficient production frontier for determining the worst relative efficiency that can be assigned to each DMU. DMUs lying on the inefficient production frontier are referred to as DEA inefficient while those neither on the efficient frontier nor on the inefficient frontier are declared DEA inefficient. It can be argued that both relative efficiencies should be considered simultaneously and any approach with only one of them would be biased. This paper proposed the integration of both efficiencies as an interval so that the overall performance score would belong to this interval. It was shown that efficiency interval provided more information than either of the two efficiencies, which was illustrated using two numerical examples.
Read moreA slacks-based measure of super-efficiency in DEA with interval data
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) is a non-parametric technique for measuring the efficiency of decision making units (DMU) with exact input and output terms. So far, a number of DEA models with interval data have been developed. The radial DEA model such as CCR or BCC model with interval data are well known as basic DEA models with interval data. However, these radial DEA models have some defects. In this study, we develop a new approach based upon the slacks-based measurement (SBM) of super-efficiency model for dealing with interval data in DEA. The SBM super-efficiency DEA model can not only discriminate the performance of efficient DMUs from inefficient ones, but can distinguish between the efficient DMUs. In addition, this model can overcome the drawback that the super-efficiency model can be infeasible under variable returns to scale (VRS) assumption. An illustrative example is provided to verify the idea of this paper and show its potential application and validity.
Read moreDEA Cross Efficiency
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) provides a relative efficiency measure for peer decision making units (DMUs) with multiple inputs and outputs. While DEA has been proven an effective approach in identifying the best practice frontiers, its flexibility in weighting multiple inputs and outputs and its nature of self-evaluation have been criticized. The cross efficiency method was developed as a DEA extension to rank DMUs with the main idea being to use DEA to do peer evaluation, rather than in pure self-evaluation mode. However, cross efficiency scores obtained from the original DEA model are generally not unique, and depend on which of the alternate optimal solutions to the DEA linear programs is used. The current chapter discusses various cross efficiency approaches in dealing with non-unique solutions from DEA
Read moreA survey on measuring efficiency through the determination of the least distance in data envelopment analysis
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to provide an outline of the major contributions in the literature on the determination of the least distance in data envelopment analysis (DEA). The focus herein is primarily on methodological developments. Specifically, attention is mainly paid to modeling aspects, computational features, the satisfaction of properties and duality. Finally, some promising avenues of future research on this topic are stated. Design/methodology/approach DEA is a methodology based on mathematical programming for the assessment of relative efficiency of a set of decision-making units (DMUs) that use several inputs to produce several outputs. DEA is classified in the literature as a non-parametric method because it does not assume a particular functional form for the underlying production function and presents, in this sense, some outstanding properties: the efficiency of firms may be evaluated independently on the market prices of the inputs used and outputs produced; it may be easily used with multiple inputs and outputs; a single score of efficiency for each assessed organization is obtained; this technique ranks organizations based on relative efficiency; and finally, it yields benchmarking information. DEA models provide both benchmarking information and efficiency scores for each of the evaluated units when it is applied to a dataset of observations and variables (inputs and outputs). Without a doubt, this benchmarking information gives DEA a distinct advantage over other efficiency methodologies, such as stochastic frontier analysis (SFA). Technical inefficiency is typically measured in DEA as the distance between the observed unit and a “benchmarking” target on the estimated piece-wise linear efficient frontier. The choice of this target is critical for assessing the potential performance of each DMU in the sample, as well as for providing information on how to increase its performance. However, traditional DEA models yield targets that are determined by the “furthest” efficient projection to the evaluated DMU. The projected point on the efficient frontier obtained as such may not be a representative projection for the judged unit, and consequently, some authors in the literature have suggested determining closest targets instead. The general argument behind this idea is that closer targets suggest directions of enhancement for the inputs and outputs of the inefficient units that may lead them to the efficiency with less effort. Indeed, authors like Aparicio et al. (2007) have shown, in an application on airlines, that it is possible to find substantial differences between the targets provided by applying the criterion used by the traditional DEA models, and those obtained when the criterion of closeness is utilized for determining projection points on the efficient frontier. The determination of closest targets is connected to the calculation of the least distance from the evaluated unit to the efficient frontier of the reference technology. In fact, the former is usually computed through solving mathematical programming models associated with minimizing some type of distance (e.g. Euclidean). In this particular respect, the main contribution in the literature is the paper by Briec (1998) on Hölder distance functions, where formally technical inefficiency to the “weakly” efficient frontier is defined through mathematical distances. Findings All the interesting features of the determination of closest targets from a benchmarking point of view have generated, in recent times, the increasing interest of researchers in the calculation of the least distance to evaluate technical inefficiency (Aparicio et al., 2014a). So, in this paper, we present a general classification of published contributions, mainly from a methodological perspective, and additionally, we indicate avenues for further research on this topic. The approaches that we cite in this paper differ in the way that the idea of similarity is made operative. Similarity is, in this sense, implemented as the closeness between the values of the inputs and/or outputs of the assessed units and those of the obtained projections on the frontier of the reference production possibility set. Similarity may be measured through multiple distances and efficiency measures. In turn, the aim is to globally minimize DEA model slacks to determine the closest efficient targets. However, as we will show later in the text, minimizing a mathematical distance in DEA is not an easy task, as it is equivalent to minimizing the distance to the complement of a polyhedral set, which is not a convex set. This complexity will justify the existence of different alternatives for solving these types of models. Originality/value As we are aware, this is the first survey in this topic.
Read moreMaking an ideal decision-making unit using virtual network data envelopment analysis approach
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) is a tool for measuring the relative efficiency of decision-making units (DMUs) that perform similar tasks. One of the uses of the DEA is the establishment of benchmarks for inefficient DMUs. These benchmarks play the role of target for inefficient DMUs. However, traditional DEA (TDEA) models fail to rank the efficient DMUs, and as a result, they cannot determine a benchmark for the inefficient DMUs. To overcome this shortcoming, this paper proposes virtual network DEA (NDEA) approach. The proposed method not only ranks the whole inefficient and efficient DMUs but also establishes a virtual benchmark called ideal DMU. The case study demonstrates the applicability of the proposed model.
Read moreA Slack-Based Measures for Improving the Efficiency Performance of Departments in Universitas Malikussaleh
Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) is a data-oriented performance evaluation method that has a very satisfactory performance when there are multiple inputs and outputs presented in the form of set of peer Decision Making Units (DMU). In the discussion of DEA, basically measures the efficiency of each DMU in specific performance based on DEA Efficiency Scores. In DEA, when there is a value of Non-Zero Input and Output Slacks then this often means inefficiency. This scalar measures directly with the input surplus and the output of the short decision of the decision making unit (DMU). Universitas Malikussaleh as one of the State Universities in Indonesia, it is necessary to follow the regulations of the Ministry of Research, Technology and Higher Education of the Republic of Indonesia (KEMENRISTEKDIKTI), one of which is the measurement of efficiency based on the number of lecturers research, the efficient use of resources included in the number of lecturers and employees, as well as students who can be accommodated based on efficiency measurements using DEA. This paper will measure the efficiency of each department in Malikussaleh University and if there is an inefficient department then it will be measured based on slack-based measures to advise aspects that need attention so that the department can be efficient.
Read moreAn Integrated DEA and PROMETHEE II Method for Complete Ranking: An Application in Life-Insurance Sector
Globally, insurance and takaful companies play a crucial role in economic and financial development of a country. Malaysia’s insurance sector has undergone substantial changes compared to two decades ago. Due to intense competition observed in Malaysian insurance industry, efficiency measurement and a complete efficiency ranking of insurance companies are very important for the decision makers so that necessary changes and improvement can be made. Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) is a non-parametric method that has been acknowledged as an effective method to measure the efficiency of homogeneous decision-making units (DMUs). The main advantage of DEA is its ability to handle multiple inputs and outputs. However, standard DEA has poor discrimination power since it generates too many efficient units especially when the number of DMUs under study is insufficient in comparison to number of inputs and outputs. It cannot discriminate efficient units and therefore unable to give a complete ranking of DMUs. This study aimed to overcome the ranking problem found in standard DEA by integrating DEA and Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluations (PROMETHEE) II. The hybrid method was applied to evaluate the efficiency and ranking of 22 life insurance and takaful companies in Malaysia from the period of 2017 to 2018. Input variables used in this study comprised of fees and commission, and management expenses. Meanwhile, output variables were net premium and generated investment income. The proposed method involved two stages. In the first stage, DEA was applied to obtain the efficient scores for the DMUs. In the second stage, PROMETHEE II was implemented to rank the efficient units. This hybrid method has successfully obtained full ranking of all the insurance companies under study. The inefficient companies can learn strategies and practices from efficient companies to enhance their services. It is recommended for future research to integrate DEA with other Multi Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) methods such as TOPSIS and VIKOR to fully rank the DMUs.
Read moreEnergy Saving and Management of the Industrial Process Based on An Improved DEA Cross-model
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) has been commonly used in the energy saving of enterprise plants. Nevertheless, when the traditional DEA model analyzes the effectiveness of decision-making units (DMUs), over 1/3 of the DMUs’ efficiency values are 1, so the traditional DEA model cannot distinguish the cons and pros of the DMUs. And although the DEA cross-model(DEACM) is able to differentiate the cons as well as pros of the effective DMUs, it can’t obtain the improvement direction of the ineffective DMUs. Therefore, an energy saving and management method based on an improved DEACM, which can use the higher efficiency distinction to identify the efficiency state of the DMUs, is proposed in this paper. Meanwhile, the improvement direction of the ineffective DMU can be found by the self-evaluation of the improved DEACM. Finally, the improved DEACM is utilized to save and manage the energy configuration of the PTA solvent system in the industrial process. The experimental results reveal that the practicality and effectiveness of the proposed method are verified, and in addition, the efficiency discrimination is well. Moreover, the proposed model can find the direction of the quantitative targets of energy saving to improve the energy efficiency of PTA production.
Read moreEnvironment and economic performance evaluation of 30 provinces and municipalities in China based on a two-stage multiplier DEA approach
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) has been widely applied in the performance evaluation of environment or economy recently. If economic and environmental systems exist simultaneously in a decision making unit (DMU), conventional DEA models generally treat the DMU as a black box, and the internal relationship of DMU is often ignored. Thus, the performance of DMUs may be overestimated. In order to solve this problem, a new two-stage multiplier DEA approach is proposed in this paper. The new model can not only obtain the efficiency score of each system, but also consider the intermediate outputs when assessing the overall efficiency of the two systems. In order to test the effectiveness of this approach, a numerical example of 30 provinces in China is illustrated.
Read moreEvaluation and benchmarking of bank branches on two-level inputs and outputs: An application of MOLP and DEA
Efficiency evaluation of homogenous decision making units (DMUs), is one of the primary objectives of data envelopment analysis (DEA), in which the large number of inputs or outputs compared with the number of DMUs leads to decreased evaluation precision of DEA models. Overcoming this problem is the main issue in two-level DEA. In the present study, we use the multi objective linear programming (MOLP) method proposed by Sumpsi et al., which is based on constructing the pay-off matrix and using goal programming (GP), to investigate this problem. Furthermore, we discuss the enhanced Russell's model for evaluating and benchmarking DMUs with two-level inputs and outputs. The proposed method is applied to 24 branches of an Iranian commercial bank.
Read moreBest-practice benchmarking using clustering methods: Application to energy regulation
Best-practice benchmarking using clustering methods: Application to energy regulation
A Fuzzy Dual SBM Model with Fuzzy Weights: An Application to the Health Sector
In this paper, we focus on measuring the performance efficiencies of decision making units (DMUs) using dual slack based measure (SBM) model with fuzzy data in data envelopment analysis (DEA). In the conventional dual SBM model, the data and the weights of input and output are found as crisp quantities. However, in real world applications, input-output data and input-output weights may have vague/uncertainty due to various factors such as quality of treatment and medicines, number of medical and non-medical staffs, number of patients, etc. in health sector. To deal with such uncertainty, we can apply fuzzy set theory. In this paper, we propose a SBM model with fuzzy weights in Fuzzy DEA (FDEA) for fuzzy input and fuzzy output. This model is then reduced to a crisp LPP by using expected values of a fuzzy number (FN). Finally, we present an application of the proposed model to the health sector, consisting of two input variables as (i) sum of number of doctors and staff nurses (ii) number of pharmacists and two output variables as (i) number of inpatients (ii) number of outpatients. Both the input variables and output variables are considered as TFNs.
Read moreExtended Non-controllable Variable Input-Output Oriented Model in DEA Analysis
Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) has been used to measure the productive efficiency of decision making units (DMUs) with multiple input and output. However, in real life, the ways to improve efficiency of DMUs is impractical because some of the inputs or outputs are uncontrollable. Thereby, using the non-controllable input output oriented model (NCNI-O), duality formulation and vector average input/output, this research is an attempt to improve the efficiency score and derive the input-output target strategy and at the same time to prove that the uncontrollable input cannot be reduce but the value should be fixed. At the end of this work, it has been proving that the objectives to maintain input and increase output or maintain output and reduce input were successfully achieved. It is also discovered the new input-output target and the results obtained indicate that the impact of uncontrollable variables is relatively significant.
Read moreUnoriented two-stage DEA: The case of the oscillating intermediate products
Unoriented two-stage DEA: The case of the oscillating intermediate products