• https://doi.org/10.29173/alr2848Copy DOI Icon

Vavilov and Generative AI

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

This article considers whether a decision made by generative artificial intelligence can satisfy the standard of reasonableness set out in Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov. Vavilov requires that administrative decisions be justified through reasons that are transparent and intelligible to the affected party. Earlier scholarship, law, and policy have assumed that AI cannot do this because it cannot provide reasons and its inner workings are opaque or uninterpretable. However, new capabilities of large language models challenge this view. Recent experiments show that when prompted with party submissions and relevant legal materials, generative AI can produce persuasive, legally grounded reasons for decisions. The article evaluates two responses: one argues that AI decisions remain unreasonable under Vavilov since their true basis lies in opaque technical processes; the other contends that Vavilov focuses on the cogency of stated reasons, not how they were generated. The article supports the latter position, suggesting that Vavilov leaves open the possibility that AI-generated decisions can be reasonable, provided their reasons meet the decision-making standard applied to human actors.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations8

Qualitatively different teacher experiences of teaching with generative artificial intelligence

  • May 26, 2025
  • International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education
  • Robert Ellis +2
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations5

Integrating Multimodal Generative AI Technologies in Postgraduate Marketing Education

  • Nov 23, 2024
  • ASCILITE Publications
  • Terrence Chong
  • Research Article

Evaluation of generative artificial intelligence (GENAI) as a transformative technology for effective and efficient governance, political knowledge, electoral, and democratic processes

  • Jul 15, 2025
  • International Journal of Business Ecosystem & Strategy (2687-2293)
  • Chiji Longinus Ezeji +1
  • Conference Article

The 3rd Workshop on Personal Intelligence with Generative AI

  • May 08, 2025
  • Yang Zhang +8
  • Research Article
  • Citations36

Decoding medical educators' perceptions on generative artificial intelligence in medical education.

  • Jun 07, 2024
  • Journal of investigative medicine : the official publication of the American Federation for Clinical Research
  • Jorge Cervantes +5
  • Conference Article
  • Citations2

Engineering Educators' Perspectives on the Impact of Generative AI in Higher Education

  • Apr 22, 2025
  • Umama Dewan +3
  • Research Article

Generative Artificial Intelligence in Urban Design: A Review of Recent Applications

  • Dec 01, 2025
  • Landscape Architecture
  • Qiyuan Hong +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations8

Medical students’ knowledge, attitudes, and practices toward generative artificial intelligence in Egypt 2024: a Cross-Sectional study

  • May 28, 2025
  • BMC Medical Education
  • Omar A Ghanem +7
  • Research Article
  • Citations15

Generative artificial intelligence vs. law students: an empirical study on criminal law exam performance

  • Jul 02, 2024
  • Law, Innovation and Technology
  • Armin Alimardani
  • Research Article

ChatGPT Class Generative Artificial Intelligence Criminal Subject Problem Thinking

  • Nov 11, 2024
  • Advances in Computer and Communication
  • Junjun Luo
  • Research Article

A Study on Generative AI in the China Media Setting Contemplated with the Nation's Economic Modernisation

  • Dec 30, 2024
  • Journal of Information Systems Engineering and Management
  • Sun Hao, Mrutyunjay Sisugoswami
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Generative artificial intelligence as a catalyst for employee happiness and sustainable performance in green hotel management

  • Dec 02, 2025
  • International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
  • Rafael Robina-Ramírez +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Health Care Professionals' Experiences and Opinions About Generative AI and Ambient Scribes in Clinical Documentation: Protocol for a Scoping Review.

  • Aug 08, 2025
  • JMIR research protocols
  • Carolina Garcia Sanchez +4
  • Research Article

Generative AI in higher education psychology programs: a scoping review exploring the opportunities for its use in assessment methods

  • Nov 02, 2025
  • Australian Psychologist
  • Sarah Halliday +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Generative AI in Self-Directed Learning: a thematic scoping review

  • Dec 30, 2025
  • Interactive Learning Environments
  • Jasper Roe +1
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.