The Sexual Politics of Empire: Postcolonial Homophobia in Haiti by Erin Durban (review)
Reviewed by: The Sexual Politics of Empire: Postcolonial Homophobia in Haiti by Erin Durban Darlène Dubuisson Erin Durban. The Sexual Politics of Empire: Postcolonial Homophobia in Haiti. Champaign: University of Illinois Press, 2023. 265 pp. What's in a term? Terms can have the power to define reality and shape material and immaterial forms of oppression, resistance, and solidary. As such, Erin Durban's The Sexual Politics of Empire: Postcolonial Homophobia in Haiti (2023) pays careful attention to the terms surrounding "same-sex-desiring and gender-creative Haitians" (1). Through a rigorous interdisciplinary lens, the book attunes to how the post-2010 earthquake circulation of imported concepts such as "LGBT" (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender) and "LGBTI" (inclusive of Intersex) by Evangelical Christians, on the one hand, and the global LGBTQI (inclusive of Queer) human rights movement, on the other, corresponded with imperialist logics of intervention. Whereas the Evangelical Christian movement—conceiving of Haiti as "too queer" (8)—forwarded the "modernization" of Haiti through the annunciation and denunciation of homosexuality, members of the global LGBTQI human rights movement—seeing Haiti as "too homophobic" (8)—sought international protections of Haiti's "LGBT community" from the purported homophobia of Haitian culture. These interventions were manifestations of what Durban theorizes as "postcolonial homophobia"—that is, "the compounded effects of historical and contemporary Western imperialist biopolitical interventions to regulate/manage/control/govern/liberate gender and sexuality" (10). Writing with the sensibility of a long-term friend and critical, self-reflective ally, Durban depicts in rich ethnographic detail how same-sex desiring and gender-creative Haitians contend with postcolonial homophobia by mobilizing Kreyòl terms of self-reference, such as masisi (male same-sex desire) and madivin (women who prefer women), and by strategically employing or resisting "the terms [End Page 419] imported from the United States that privilege same-sex desire" (4). This book is, in effect, a treatise of the terms (here, I mean vocabulary as well as periods, relations/tensions, and conditions) of sexual politics in post-colonial Haiti. The book consists of two parts: 1) a transnational history of European colonialism and United States imperialism in Haiti and 2) ethnographic descriptions of the "episodic 'flare-ups' of homophobic violence" occurring in Haiti between 2008 and 2016 (18). Although the book moves chronologically, it is scattered across time and space. The chapter organization, Durban contends, is meant to "impart a sense of displacements, disruptions, continuities, dispersals, and accretions over time" (18). While the book succeeds at conveying this sense, its omission of important (to my mind) historical moments and structural analyses, e.g., the Duvalier dictatorship era and the contours of neoliberalism in Haiti, create unnecessary gaps in the narrative. This critique is different from saying that the book is structurally lacking. On the contrary, the book is well-organized, covering much ground through its partial and episodic approach. The first two chapters of the book provide a queer transnational history of imperialism and colonialism in Haiti, which addresses the question: "'For whom and by whom has sexuality been defined [in colonialist and imperialist contexts]'" (Pérez 2003:125, cited in Durban, 25). In answer to this question, Durban traces Western imperialist perversion of the zonbi—an Afro-Haitian concept of the living dead that served as "a referent to racial capitalism" (27)—to discuss the emergence and circulation of Euro-U.S. discourse of Haiti as "the dark and dangerous premodern land of Voodoo (English)/Vaudoux (French)" (6). As Durban clarifies, the "'voodoo/vaudoux' of this discourse is a white Euro-U.S. imaginary—or really, a nightmarish fantasy of Haitian Vodou" (6)—the popular syncretic religion that merges Roman Catholicism and Afro-Indigenous religious traditions. In the first chapter, Durban maps the perversion of the zonbi through what they delineate as the "five periods of transnational Haitian history that profoundly shape contemporary queer sexual politics: European colonialism (1492-1791), the Haitian Revolution (1791-1804), the Black republic (1804-1915), the first U.S. occupation (1915-34), and the early years of the AIDS epidemic (1980s-1990s)" (22). Durban first considers how enslaved Africans brought the concept of the zonbi with them through the Middle Passage and how this notion...
Read more