Victorian Coral Islands of the Empire, Mission, and the Boys' Adventure Novel by Michelle Elleray
Reviewed by: Victorian Coral Islands of the Empire, Mission, and the Boys' Adventure Novel by Michelle Elleray Alisa Clapp-Itnyre (bio) Victorian Coral Islands of the Empire, Mission, and the Boys' Adventure Novel, by Michelle Elleray. Routledge, 2020. (Series: Studies in Childhood, 1700 to the Present) An outgrowth of the author's dissertation, Victorian Coral Islands represents research across the globe, from archives in New Zealand, England, Canada, and the US, all of which provide useful historical documents to enrich chapters focused on a handful of British boys' midcentury adventure novels and stories. The book's introduction and five chapters explore, in order, the Juvenile Missionary Magazine (1844–87), chapter 1; Frederick Marryat's Masterman Ready; or The Wreck of the Pacific (1841–42), chapter 2; R. M. Ballantyne's The Coral Island: A Tale of the Pacific Ocean (1857), chapter 3; two novels by W. H. G. Kingston, Little Ben Hadden; or, Do Right, Whatever Comes of It (1870) and Kidnapping in [End Page 304] the Pacific, Or, The Adventures of Boas Ringdon: A Long Yarn in Four Lengths (1879), chapter 4; and, to end, Robert Louis Stevenson's late-century response, the novella The Ebb-Tide: A Trio and Quartette (1894). Taking a postcolonial approach, Elleray looks closely at the books' island locales as sites of colonialist pressure. She focuses upon the socially marginalized characters of these stories: the young, the working-class sailor, and the Pacific Islander convert, arguing that each needs special attention, particularly the latter, who has been limited to stereotypes of either the cannibal or the maiden (3). Her specific analysis is of empire and missionary culture. Using the concepts of "articulation" and "entanglement," she suggests both are "deeply imbricated, such that an analysis of one is not fully intelligible without reference to the other" (6), a form of Stuart Hall's concept of articulation; further, they are also "entangled" (a concept borrowed from Nicholas Thomas), which "emphasizes the accidental and the unresolved, the destructive and the generative" (6) within these institutions even as they remain "resistant to efforts to render them separate or distanced" (7). Recognizing that her three focal authors were all Christian evangelicals of some kind, favorite authors of the Sunday school reward book enterprise, Elleray emphasizes the importance of focusing on such fiction when many children's literature scholars like J. S. Bratton only examine late-century boys' adventure fiction as supposedly part of the trend away from didactic evangelical literature (7). Elleray is not the first scholar to examine fiction of the Coral Islands, but she is one of the first to examine it in the context of children's literature. These islands were important to Britain's South Pacific colonialist outreach. Invoking the theory of Michel Foucault on "heterotopia"—places where a change of identity occurs such as the Polynesian village (13–14)—she points to these islands as that important site for Britain's cultural imagination, a garden of Eden yet inhabited by "fallen people" needing the intervention of Christian missionaries (16). In focusing on the Coral Islands, Elleray also builds on the work of Ann Elias's Coral Empire: Underwater Oceans, Colonial Tropics, Visual Modernity (2019) and Rod Edmond's Representing the South Pacific: Colonial Discourse from Cook to Gauguin (1997). Using their concepts, she reminds us of the symbolism of coral, a grouping of which is called a "colony" and the expansion of which is referred to as "colonizing" (4). Further, she unpacks the then-science of small coral polyps forming the basis of entire islands, which became symbolic of the smallest of children and their impact on the colonial enterprise of the nineteenth century. [End Page 305] Chapter 1, "The Juvenile Missionary Magazine: Agency and Discipline," first examines the importance of the John Williams, a missionary ship first launched in 1844 thanks in large part to the monetary donations of children and which continued to be used by missionary magazines as an important trope for children's agency in the missionary movement (34). Likewise, the concept of coral polyps became not only a useful metaphor for Victorians of the power of spiritual fortitude, as captured in the journal The Coral Missionary Magazine (42), but...
Read more