- Research Article
13
- 10.1093/cdj/bsaa032
Reimagining Livelihoods: Life Beyond Economy, Society, and Environment
- Sep 07, 2020
- Community Development Journal
- Patrick Bresnihan
In July 2020, the Irish Green Party entered into a coalition Government with the two historically dominant parties in Irish politics, Fianna Fail and Fine Gael. The decision to enter Government came after heated debate amongst the Party members over the proposed Programme for Government. At the heart of this debate was whether you could separate climate action from social and economic justice. This was not just a matter of idealism versus pragmatism, as the mainstream media tended to portray it. It was more fundamentally a disagreement over the categories of economy, society, and environment. Are work and housing any less ‘environmental’ than biodiversity loss and pollution? As Ethan Miller’s book, Reimagining Livelihoods, outlines, the cultures of thought that make this question so challenging have a long and deep history. Ethan explains early on where his own intellectual concern with the ‘hegemonic trio’ of economy, society, and environment began. He describes being involved in a campaign against a proposed tourist development in Plum Creek, Maine, where he lives and works, and where the book is firmly situated. The 5-year conflict over the development served, he argues, to affirm, rather than challenge, the separate categories of economy, society, and environment. This was evident in the binary framing of ‘jobs versus environment’, for example, or the overly technical and economistic framing of diverse social and environmental concerns. In Maine, for example, the environment has historically meant material resources—timber, fish, minerals. Today, even as the material extraction of these resources dwindles, the environment is re-made as a resource for attracting tourists—‘amenities’. What is consistent is the idea that the environment is a domain of ‘things to be used, managed, or avoided’.
Read more