Preventing fitna, promoting schism: a microhistory of conversion in mandate Palestine
ABSTRACT The history of Christian missionary activity in the Middle East is vast and rich, informing the development of European domination over the Ottoman Empire and the colonial expansions of the twentieth century from Egypt to Iraq. But on the tip of such long-term and geographically expansive narratives always stood the very human subjects whose lives were transformed by encounters with missionaries. These stories call upon historians to be scrutinised in their local and period-specific contexts and to reveal how religious conversions, and the forms of resisting them, were experienced and understood by societies living through them. This article offers a microhistory of a forgotten and seemingly insignificant story of the conversion of a young Muslim man that occurred in 1931 in the city of Gaza, southern Palestine. A nationwide scandal at first, the story had sunk into oblivion within several years, overshadowed by the fateful history of mandate Palestine and Gaza in particular. However, if microhistories intentionally aim to extract the meaning of past lifeworlds from the mundane and forsaken, the conversion of ‘Ali al-Khilfawi emerges to be quite telling. By recounting contemporary ways of making sense of this event, the article suggests three arguments that refute the common understanding of conversion as a manifestation of inter-religious struggle. Gazans, and Palestinians writ large, were not seeing conversion this way. Instead, Gazans understood conversion as a result of specific political circumstances and personal choices, rather than as a direct consequence of the mission itself. Secondly, while the mission is often taken to be an arm of colonialism, in protesting against conversion, Gazans utilised the very language and regulations introduced by the British government. These were means of curbing and criminalising the Palestinian struggle against Zionism and imperial rule. By using them, Gazans utilised a colonial instrument against itself. And finally, if the conversion of a Muslim man could have been an opening for sectarian strife, the Palestinian understanding of religious struggle tended to be within one’s own religion, and in this case, within Christianity rather than versus Muslims.
Read more