Romantic Necromancy:Reading and Writing as Ghost-Seeing Dale Townshend (bio) Romantic Shades and Shadows by Susan J. Wolfson. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press, 2018. 272 pp. Cloth $64.95. To read Romanticism is inevitably to engage with the world of spirits. As our mechanisms of sensemaking and interpretation plot their course over the moribund surfaces of words on the page, so we revivify and activate their latent potential, initiating language into a complex yet subtle dance of spectral signification as we do so. Such, as least, is the opening and underlying claim of Susan J. Wolfson's Romantic Shades and Shadows (2018), a brilliant and engaging critical "performance" of ghostliness as it manifests itself across a broad range of Romantic and postRomantic poetry and prose. Although, by dint of its title alone, one might have expected of this book a contribution to the long-standing debate concerning the relationship between Romanticism and the Gothic, this is not the welltrodden path that Wolfson chooses to follow here. Instead, Romantic Shades and Shadows refreshingly turns away from the ghouls that gibber and rattle their chains through the works of Horace Walpole, Matthew Gregory Lewis, and their contemporaries in order to set its sights upon an altogether different spectral realm, one that resides not so much in representations or textual figurings of "actual" ghosts as in the ghostly workings of literary language itself. For, as Wolfson in her introductory first chapter points out, this is a book that is primarily concerned with "spectral linguistic agencies" (2), [End Page 485] with the "apparitional presences in the finely grained textures of writing" (4), with the shadows that are conjured in and by words but which are often rendered legible only through careful and attentive acts of reading. Nonetheless, the more familiar shades of the Gothic return early on in the study when, in a moment of particularly arresting analysis, Wolfson locates the precedents for her own reading practice in Gothic fiction's most primal of scenes: Emily St Aubert's illicit perusal of her late father's letters in Ann Radcliffe's The Mysteries of Udolpho (1794). Here, and as both refracted and amplified in Jane Austen's semi-parodic Northanger Abbey (written 1798–99; published late 1817; dated 1818), it is not a menacing ghoul from the past that so haunts the heroine but the ghostly words that appear on the page before her very eyes (in the case of Radcliffe) or the "ghost stories" that crowd in upon the heroine's mind (in Austen). The hauntings in and of Romanticism, Wolfson thus persuasively demonstrates, are primarily the functions of language, and inhere in those fleeting linguistic presences—echoes, parallels, homonyms, repetitions, homophones, allusions, litotes, buried etymologies—that are all too often elided when Romantic-era literature is pressed into the service of crude historicist criticism. This is to say that, though she is certainly inspired by Jerome J. McGann's influential The Romantic Ideology (1983) and the ghostly deconstructive turns of Jacques Derrida's Specters of Marx (1993) and other later works, Wolfson is duty bound by neither. Instead, she sensitively takes her cue from the ways in which such Romantic writers as Radcliffe, William Wordsworth, S. T. Coleridge, William Hazlitt, and John Keats themselves read, and were haunted by, the work of Shakespeare, identifying in their perusal of Hamlet the practice of "literary reading" that, as she describes it, is "close, slow, careful, and open to various, not necessarily reconcilable, energies in the movements of language" (3). If this is a critical methodology that recalls that of the often unfairly maligned Cleanth Brooks in The Well Wrought Urn (1947), it is an inevitability of which a rightly unapologetic Wolfson is all too aware. Here, though, the new critical practice of close reading, far from being forever doomed to ineffectual prattle about irony, paradox, and ambiguity, emerges as a powerful technique of necromancy and conjuration, a critical strategy that remains finely attuned to Romanticism's "strange byways of writing," to "haunted recalls and recognitions," to "phantasms of a future," and to "spectral presences as shapes of composition" (4). Having provided in the opening chapter an illuminating account of the "Ghost-Theory" of...
Read more