- Research Article
- 10.1111/ddi.70183
Resolving the ‘Identification Gap’ to Uncover Sympatric Seabird Distributions
- Apr 01, 2026
- Diversity and Distributions
- Simon B Z Gorta + 1 more +1
ABSTRACT Aim Accurate identification underpins effective conservation, shaping our understanding of species distributions and conservation. Yet for many taxa, diagnostic criteria remain poorly resolved, creating an ‘identification gap’ that limits the capacity of scientists and environmental managers to study, monitor, and protect them. We examined the identification of the White‐faced Storm Petrel Pelagodroma marina complex in the Southwest Pacific as a case study to develop a systematic, trait‐based approach for distinguishing closely related taxa and to apply these criteria to determine their distributions. Location Marine and island ecosystems across the Southwest Pacific. Methods Using nine categorically scored phenotypic traits for 1011 individuals from citizen science photographs, museum specimens, and available literature and online resources, we applied a polytomous variable latent class analysis to identify combinations of traits that distinguished among individuals, irrespective of their distributions. Results The optimal model incorporated four traits ( rump colour , rump extent , collar, and tail shape ) of which only rump colour and tail shape were required to distinguish three latent classes which aligned broadly with the distributions of the three recognised subspecies present in the study region. These results revealed records of the ‘Nationally Critical’ and poorly‐known Kermadec Storm Petrel P. m. albiclunis from south‐eastern Australia, far beyond their core distribution and showed that Australian and Aotearoa/New Zealand taxa often make cross‐Tasman movements, offering novel and management‐relevant insights into their at‐sea distributions. Main Conclusions Our approach quantitatively validated field identification features and demonstrates how citizen science photographs and museum collections can be used to bridge the ‘identification gap’. Publicly available datasets from which traits can be quantified offer an opportunity to robustly address this gap. Our objective, trait‐based framework offers a generalisable and scalable approach for resolving identification challenges in hard‐to‐identify, threatened, and cryptic taxa globally.
Read more