- Research Article
- 10.48084/etasr.15778
A Novel Approach for Criteria Weight Determination: A Case Study in Machine Ranking
- Feb 09, 2026
- Engineering Technology & Applied Science Research
- Tran Van Dua
Machine ranking plays a crucial role in manufacturing, influencing both economic efficiency and technical performance. However, this task is inherently complex because each machine must be evaluated simultaneously across multiple, often conflicting, criteria. This challenge highlights the need for Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) methods. This study proposes a new criteria weighting approach, the SITDER method, that aims to improve the stability of machine ranking results across different MCDM techniques. SITDER integrates two methods: Skewness Impact Through Distributional Evaluation (SITDE) and Rank Order Centroid (ROC). In the first stage, SITDE is used to determine the relative importance of the criteria. In the second stage, ROC is applied to compute the final criterion weights. The effectiveness of SITDER was validated using two case studies involving the ranking of 13 handheld polishers and 12 grinding machines. In both examples, the rank correlation coefficients among the MCDM methods were consistently higher when using SITDER compared to SITDE alone. In Example 1, the average Spearman coefficient increased from 0.6282 (SITDE) to 0.739 (SITDER). In Example 2, it increased from 0.9643 to 0.9744. These results demonstrate that SITDER is a highly effective weighting method and a valuable addition to the set of available criteria weighting techniques.
Read more