- Research Article
- 10.1080/17508061.2026.2655051
Of Mandarin(s), (m)other tongues, and dubbing: Sonolingual composition in Taiwan cinema beyond A City of Sadness
- Apr 01, 2026
- Journal of Chinese Cinemas
- Cameron L White
A City of Sadness (1989) has long attracted Western scholarly attention for its linguistic diversity and aural politics, with many analyses repeating the inaccurate claim that City was the first Taiwanese film to use sync sound rather than post-production dubbing. Such an overinvestment in linguistic and sonic fidelity as a means of deriving knowledge of Taiwan can delimit Taiwanese film historiography. This article develops the concept of ‘sonolingual composition’ to deconstruct the shifting relationship among body, language, and voice in Taiwan cinema, with two films as case studies. First comes a discursive analysis of attitudes toward dubbing in 1970s guoyupian. Anxiety over the tension between realism and linguistic orthodoxy was most acute when top-billed stars opened their mouths, with the half-dubbed, half-sync sound A Journey of Love (1978) a provocative example. Second comes a look at localized Hong Kong cinema in the 80s and 90s, with a particular focus on Shi Banyu’s dubbing work for Stephen Chow. Shi’s bravura turn in the parallel Mandarin and Taigi dubs of Flirting Scholar (1993) illustrate how even as there was a space for linguistic pluralism in the post-marital law era, demand for a particular star affect could constrain vocal performance.
Read more