- Research Article
- 10.14713/jjs.v15i1.265
Book Review
- Jul 09, 2024
- Journal of Jazz Studies
- Hannah Krall
Problematic metaphors about New Orleans jazz occur rampantly in jazz history.Comparing the music to a melting pot, mosaic, and even gumbo attempts to capture its multicultural influences.Caroline Vzina challenges these romanticized ideas by demonstrating the profound impact of Creole culture on jazz's formation.In Jazz La Creole: French Creole Music & The Birth of Jazz, Vzina dispels the myth that only Creole habaneras and quadrilles shaped jazz's development.Rather this culture's contributions span over a century beginning with the first enslaved Africans in Louisiana.Drawing extensively on primary sources, this book is divided into two sections, "The Precursors of Jazz," which include folk, religious, and dance music, and "Early Jazz."With these, Vzina provides a necessary, if imperfect, revision to the narrative surrounding the music of a complex ethnic group in New Orleans.First, Vzina explores the meaning of the word "creole," taking the reader through its Portuguese and Spanish origins during the seventeenth century to its use in Louisiana to describe both white and Black people born in the New World during the nineteenth century.Vzina uses creolization, despite the theory's complicated history, to describe jazz's creation, "for it better represents the intricate multilayered, and dynamic aspect of the process during which various elements of diverse cultures get intertwined as people adapt to new or changing environments in which creolized products or practices can themselves be part of a new process of creolization" (9). 1 Vzina elaborates on creolization's complex history and its prior uses in a section in the appendix, but commits to the theory anyway because of its ability to represent cultural interactions.In her work, creolization is combined with Mark Slobin's work on micromusics and those musics' involvement with subcultures.The chapter closes with insight from firsthand accounts of white and Black creoles to explain their experience 1 Anthropologist Richard Price has warned scholars about the implications of using such theories because of its entanglement with crolisation and globalization.
Read more