Getting away with murder? The suppression of coroners' inquests in early Victorian England and Wales.
Coroners’ records and newspaper reports of inquests are essential sources for local studies of homicide, suicide or fatal accidents, but in some parts of the country violent deaths that occurred in the 1840s and 1850s may be significantly under-recorded in this material. Historian and barrister J.D.J. Havard drew attention to the actions taken in this period by the magistrates of several counties in order to reduce the number of inquests held on fatal accidents and sudden natural deaths.1 His interest lay in the ease with which homicides could be concealed, and his emphasis was on those counties where the tightest restrictions were imposed. However, as magistrates had substantial freedom in managing county administration, there were widespread variations between counties, which Havard did not explore. In some counties, the actions of the magistrates led to a dramatic reduction in the number of inquests that were held, but in others the coroners continued to exercise their discretion without hindrance, or within loosely constructed local guidelines. An understanding of the nature and extent to which a particular county was affected is relevant to any analysis of the records of violent deaths in a local population. It can also lead the historian to additional records created to help the magistrates implement their chosen strategy or monitor their coroners’ activities, and these may provide useful supplementary information. This article aims to provide a broad overview of the nature and extent of the restrictions, together with details of the sources where county-specific information may be obtained.
Read more