Repeatability and reproducibility of maximum diameter measurements of prostate lesions on MRI with repositioning and variation of imaging sequences: A test-retest study.
To assess variability of maximum diameter measurements of prostate lesions in MRI assessing patient repositioning, rater and sequence effects. Forty-two patients were included retrospectively, who received a clinical bi-/multiparametric prostate MRI examination and agreed to have the T2-weighted (T2WI) and diffusion weighted-imaging (DWI) sequences scanned twice. Maximum diameter measurements of prostate lesions mentioned in the clinical radiologist reports were performed by four readers in multiple reading sessions for determination of inter-sequence (between two DWI sequences), inter-scan (between clinical and additional scan), intra-rater and inter-rater variability. The primary calculated metrics were the repeatability and reproducibility coefficient (RC/RDC), including pooled RC/RDC. Variability measured by RCs/RDCs was lowest for measurements obtained within the same reading session, with inter-scan RCs up to 5.6mm/6.5mm for T2WI/DWI, pooled RCs of 4.8mm/5.8mm, respectively, and inter-sequence RDCs of 5.4mm-5.9mm, pooled RDC 5.8mm. Measurements performed in separate reading sessions demonstrated significantly higher variability for both settings in the majority of cases (RCs: up to 10.9mm/11.7mm/10.2mm for T2WI/DWI/inter-sequence, p≤0.002), pooled RCs/RDCs 9.2mm-9.9mm. Measurements necessarily generated in different reading sessions, i.e., intra-rater or inter-rater, demonstrated high variability (RCs/RDCs up to 11.4mm/11.5mm for T2WI/DWI). Prostate lesion measurements demonstrate considerable variability. When measured in one reading session by one rater, lesion diameter differences below the pooled RCs of 4.8mm, 95%-CI [3.9, 5.6] for T2WI and 5.8mm, 95%-CI [4.7, 7.1] for DWI should not necessarily assumed to be true biological change, as these differences may result from measurement- or repositioning-based variability alone. Caution needs to be taken assessing size changes.
Read more