Silent Teachers: Turkish Books and Oriental Learning in Early Modern Europe, 1544–1669. by Nil Ö.Palabıyık. Abingdon: Routledge, 2024, 247 pp. £100.00. ISBN 9780367359782 (hb).
by Nil . Palabyk is a valuable addition to the fields of transcultural intellectual history and studies of the relationship between Christendom and the Ottoman empire.In five chronologically arranged chapters, Palabyk takes us through the narrative of the emergence of Turkish linguistic studies in Europe, from the relatively intellectually humble (and, in Palabyk's view, overstated in their importance) 1540s beginnings of Bartholomew Georgievits and Guillaume Postel through the new methods of Scaliger and the first printed Turkish grammars of Hieronymus Megiser and Andr Du Ryer to the paradigm shift towards a more systematic study of Turkish in Leiden in the 1630s, spearheaded by figures such as Anton Deusing and Jacob Anton Golius.The focus, as the author explains, is on Paris, German university towns, and Leiden, bypassing Venice, Rome, and Vienna, all important centres for oriental learning in early modern Christendom.This focus allows Palabyk to illuminate a particular network of historical actors who influenced each other (3).Palabyk provides a historiographical overview of the recent studies into Venice and Vienna to further contextualise Silent Teachers.Silent Teachers offers new arguments, frameworks and methods for the study of the subject at hand.First and foremost, the book demonstrates that European intellectuals were interested in the study of Turkish, both as an aid for better understanding of Arabic, and as an intellectual pursuit in its own right.It is important to highlight this latter argument, as the significance of learning Turkish as a goal in itself is not undisputed among scholars of early modern intellectual history.Silent Teachers makes several conceptual contributions.It emphasises the (sometimes involuntary, in cases of plagiarism) collaborative nature of early modern epistemology, and cautions against a hagiographical 'Great Men' approach to the subject.This argument is the direct result of Palabyk's methodological framework.She focuses on manuscript in addition, and often above and beyond, print, and argues that the Ottoman manuscripts collected by European scholars extended far greater influence than language teachers, assistants and printed media.Consequently, Turkish study in Christian Europe was shaped by the work of Ottoman lexicographers and followed 'the changing scholarly culture and learned practices of the Ottoman Empire' (209).Palabyk's work with printed sources focuses on marginalia and differences between specific individual copies of books.This methodological reimagining of learning Turkish in Christian Europe leads to specific challenges to existing
Read more