- Research Article
5
- 10.2307/136110
Scale and Aggregation Effects in U.S. Manufacturing: Evidence on Returns to Capital
- Apr 01, 1996
- The Canadian Journal of Economics
- Catherine J Morrison + 1 more +1
The existence and magnitude of scale economies for firms has long been an important issue. Identifying and measuring the factors affecting scale relationships is, however, difficult since they encompass a wide range of interactions related to a broadly defined notion of Short run scale effects are due to substitution constrained by fixity of private capital; long run (internal) scale economies result from utilizing the technology embodied in existing capital more efficiently as production expands; and external scale effects arise from technological factors associated with industryor economy-wide capital accumulation, which increases input-effectiveness. A number of such external or shift factors have been identified in traditional productivity or endogenous growth models, most of which can be expressed in terms of an increase in the availability or effectiveness of either physical or human capital. These include regulations, public infrastructure, R&D, and changes in the composition and quality of the labour force and capital stock, in addition to the more generic notion of disembodied or exogenous technical change. A combination of these scale effects and internal scale economies drives observed fluctuations and growth of firms and industries. Untangling the complex interactions involved requires a model that explicitly incorporates the various scale factors. In this paper we begin to shed some light on these interactions and the resulting pattern of internal and external scale effects in U.S. manufacturing. First, we provide a theoretical structure that can be used to identify the external and internal effects embodied in observed cost-output relationships. We then apply this framework to data at different levels of aggregation -aggregating from the 4-digit manufacturing level to 2-digit and then to total manufacturing -to assess whether identifiable patterns or biases emerge in
Read more