- Research Article
- 10.1080/25785648.2025.2578568
‘The Poles Were Worse than the Germans’ Revisiting Israeli Attitudes Towards the Role of Poles in the Holocaust
- Oct 02, 2025
- The Journal of Holocaust Research
- Yossi Kugler
ABSTRACT Israelis widely recognize the Germans' primary role in orchestrating the Holocaust. However, there is a tendency among some to attribute a higher degree of complicity and direct involvement to the Poles than historical evidence supports. This extends beyond even the highest scholarly estimates of Polish involvement in the deaths of up to 200,000 Jews. The claim that ‘the Poles were worse than the Germans’ has become a familiar refrain in Israeli discourse, reinforced by statements such as former Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir’s remark in 1989 that ‘Poles suckle antisemitism with their mother's milk,’ a sentiment echoed by Foreign Minister Israel Katz in 2019. What accounts for these Israeli attitudes toward the role of Poles in the Holocaust? Various explanations have been proposed, including the sense of betrayal by neighbors, the deep imprint of Holocaust memory on Israeli society, and the potential influence of Israeli high school trips to Poland. However, these factors alone do not fully explain the phenomenon. This article presents an additional and significant factor shaping Israeli perceptions: the bias of historical sources. Jews who were sent to extermination camps in Poland directly witnessed German perpetrators – whether during deportations, arrival at the camps, or in the gas chambers. However, as Primo Levi observed, ‘We, the survivors, are not the true witnesses […] Those who saw the Gorgon have not returned to tell about it.’ The vast majority of Holocaust testimonies come from those who survived, and in the case of Polish Jews, survivors frequently interacted with Poles while fleeing, hiding, or seeking refuge in forests. As a result, many survivors' experiences disproportionately emphasized Polish collaboration, betrayal, and antisemitism, reinforcing the widespread perception in Israel that ‘the Poles were as bad as, or worse than, the Germans.’
Read more