- Research Article
- 10.15699/tc.30.2025.10
On Reconstructing the Shorter Edition of the Book of Jeremiah: A Review of Michael B. Shepherd’s <i>A Commentary on Jeremiah</i>
- Nov 01, 2025
- TC: A Journal of Biblical Textual Criticism
- Matthew B Quintana
Abstract In his recent commentary on the book of Jeremiah, Michael B. Shepherd has made a novel contribution by basing his translation and exegesis on the shorter edition of Jeremiah reflected by the Old Greek (OG) translation and two witnesses from Qumran (4QJerb, d). Giving preference to the Hebrew source behind OG as the more original form of the book of Jeremiah, he argues that the MT presents a systematically revised edition of Jeremiah reflecting a historization of the prophetic material, which stands in contrast to the more open-ended, eschatological version of the shorter edition. Alongside his translation and commentary, Shepherd provides a reconstruction of the entire Hebrew Vorlage behind OG-Jeremiah. This review engages critically with Shepherd’s contribution as it relates specifically to textual scholarship on the book of Jeremiah and other attempts at reconstructing either the Vorlage of OG-Jeremiah or the shorter Hebrew edition of Jeremiah. Attention is given to key methodological questions that must be accounted for in both retroverting OG and reconstructing Jeremiah’s shorter edition, as well as to the importance of a nuanced and comprehensive account of OG-Jeremiah’s translation technique. It is concluded that, despite its ingenuity and many commendable features, Shepherd’s work is hindered by numerous shortcomings and does not achieve a definitive reconstruction of the shorter edition of Jeremiah upon which future scholarship can build without extensive revision.
Read more