The farm crisis of the 1980s, which took place in a nation where barely 2 percent of the population currently farm, is largely forgotten. However, the causes of the steep economic downturn—high inflation and rapid deflation—were replicated a few years later in the Savings and Loan debacle, and during the much more serious subprime recession of 2008. In each case, borrowers bought land and homes in an inflationary market and were forced to pay off expensive mortgages in a climate of deflation.Pamela Riney-Kehrberg's most striking contribution in When a Dream Dies is to utilize the papers of two Republican governors: Robert Ray and Terry Branstad. Hitherto these materials were unavailable to researchers. Farmers who were distressed wrote thousands of letters to the governors outlining their straitened circumstances and pleaded for relief. These letters give insights into the financial and psychological trauma of a distressed farm population. However, they are less useful to gauge the situation of the Iowa farm population as a whole, given that around 60 percent did not suffer the indignity of the forced sale of land and equipment, the need to seek off-farm employment, or the ignominy of bankruptcy.The agricultural establishment—the Extension Service, the Farm Bureau, most of the agricultural press, and the Iowa state government—were slow to detect the dangers of the downturn. Riney-Kehrberg provides a balanced analysis of how these institutions eventually met the challenge of the crisis. Her discussion of the boom years of the late 1970s and early 1980s is insightful. Before the establishment mobilized, a loose coalition of neopopulists stepped into the breach to aid the farm community. The Iowa Farm Unity Coalition, in the shape of PrairieFire and Catholic Rural Life, made the most vital contributions. On the other hand, the American Agricultural Movement was overshadowed in Iowa by locally based organizations. PrairieFire borrowed tactics from the civil rights movement, and with a call-in hotline it began to assist farms under stress. In particular, PrairieFire learned to expertly manipulate the media. Television stations eagerly covered protests, which pressured the state government to intervene. Iowa's major paper, the Des Moines Register, provided expert and extensive coverage throughout the 1980s.Riley-Kehrberg's previous work on the lives of farm women and children is especially salient. For while she explores the travails of male farmers and their struggles with banks and the Farm Credit System, she gives farm women kudos for their willingness to assist in the struggle to confront the rigidity of bankers to negotiate delinquent loans. Only when the state government mobilized and introduced a moratorium on farm foreclosures did lenders alter their tactics. Although violence was almost nonexistent in Iowa, one particular incident—a farmer murdered a loan officer in late 1985—jolted the establishment to action. Similarly, shame, guilt, psychological strain, and ignominy of the loss of a farm, saw male farm suicides increase in the 1980s. Iowa's record, however, was less serious than in bordering states. By the fall of 1985 the Iowa farm crisis moved toward its partial resolution phase. The unwieldy bankruptcy laws were tailored to the needs of farmers when Chapter 12 was written; the Extension Service introduced new programs and literature; Republican politicians began to sound like neopopulists; and vitally, arbitration instead of confrontation forced the Farm Credit System and the banks toward forbearance when they dealt with indebtedness. One special irony was that some farm families, whose job it was to produce food, had to utilize the Food Stamp program to eat.How did the farm crisis affect Iowa in the long term? Early in the book the Committee on Economic Development is mentioned. This obscure organization championed the rationalization of the economy and, in particular, that farming should jettison its excess population and push farmers toward the nonfarm sector. The farm crisis obviously quickened this process. Most counties lost farmers, small towns and businesses suffered, and school consolidations took place. Farm children decided to pursue other careers, and after high school or college they moved to Iowa cities or out of state. Many farm women took off-farm jobs, and if a family remained on the land, the husband often farmed part-time. State government sought to bolster revenue. By the mid-1980s gambling was legalized: horse and dog race tracks and riverboat casinos enticed Iowans to spend their disposable income. State politics changed. In the 1960s and 1970s, Iowa saw close competition between parties. By the twenty-first century the state grew more conservative; Republicans dominated statewide offices, with Democrats only competitive in the metro areas.In sum, Riney-Kehrberg puts a human face on the Iowa farm crisis of the 1980s. She avoids, for the most part, a close analysis of the complexities of the financial downturn, but she gauges the trauma of the times for all members of the farm family in this handsomely produced book.
Read more