- Preprint Article
1
- 10.1101/2025.10.09.25337422
Association of Electronic Cigarette Use with Chronic Kidney Disease in NHANES 2017-2020: A Replication Study
- Oct 13, 2025
- medRxiv
- Gal Cohen + 2 more +2
Combustible cigarette (CC) smoking is a modifiable risk factor for chronic kidney disease (CKD), but the CKD risk associated with electronic cigarette (EC) use, relative to CC use or nonuse, is unclear. We read with interest a recent analysis (Li et al., 2025) of the NHANES 2017-2020 database that evaluated this research question. In the course of verifying the results, we identified multiple concerns in the reported methodology including a) not a priori segmenting into CC current, former, and never use to minimize confounding between CC and EC use in subsequent analysis; b) unclear rationale for excluding ~80% of the available sample; and c) performing a sensitivity analysis on an EC cohort with n=1 harm events. The present replication study indicates that, after segmenting for CC use history and adjusting for covariates, particularly former smoking, there was no association between EC current use (past 5 days) and CKD risk in this NHANES population. This replication study highlights how precise segmentation and characterization of exposure to all tobacco products is required for accurate analysis of cross-sectional studies and suggests metrics for incorporation into future waves of NHANES.
Read more