A surrogate‐based iterative importance sampling method for structural reliability analysis

In this paper, an efficient technique is developed to predict failure probability of three failure modes(case rupture, fracture and bolt breakage) related to solid rocket motor case due to the inner pressure during the mission flight. The overall procedure consists of the steps: 1) design parameters affecting the case failure are identified and their uncertainties are modelled by probability distribution, 2) combustion analysis in the interior of the case is carried out to obtain maximum expected operating pressure(MEOP), 3) stress and other structural performances are evaluated by finite element analysis(FEA), and 4) failure probabilities are calculated for the above mentioned failure modes. Axi-symmetric assumption for FEA is employed for simplification while contact between bolted joint is accounted for. Efficient procedure is developed to evaluate failure probability which consists of finding first an Most Probable Failure Point(MPP) using First-Order Reliability Method(FORM), next making a response surface model around the MPP using Latin Hypercube Sampling(LHS), and finally calculating failure probability by employing Importance Sampling.

Reliability is a critical indicator for evaluating the safety and performance of mechanical structures. Surrogate models are widely employed in reliability analysis to reduce computational costs; however, their accuracy strongly depends on the quality of training samples. This paper proposes an uncertainty and distance-driven sequential sampling deep neural network method (UDDS-DNN) for structural reliability analysis. First, initial training samples were generated from the Monte Carlo population (MCP) using the Minimax sampling strategy. This ensured global coverage of the random variable space. Then, the predictive uncertainty of the DNN was quantified using the Jackknife-based method. The estimated uncertainty, inter-sample distance, and probabilistic characteristics of the input random variables were considered. The adaptive learning function was constructed to guide sequential sample enrichment. The proposed method was validated through two numerical examples and three engineering case studies. Results demonstrated that UDDS-DNN achieves high accuracy and computational efficiency in multivariate, nonlinear, and complex structural reliability problems. The method provided an effective solution for reliability analysis of complex structures using DNN-based sequential sampling.

An optimization method for learning statistical classifiers in structural reliability

Use of approximations for calculating the structural failure probability under uncertainties is a necessary aspect. But efficient use of suitable approximations at different stages of reliability prediction and design makes this valuable tool practical for many large scale structures. The objective of this paper is to address the modern approximation concepts and their utility in structural reliability estimation. Emphasis is placed on building the higher order approximations using intervening variables to closely represent the nonlinear limit state functions. The most probable failure point (MPP) search can be carried either in X-space or U-space for a wide variety of random variable distributions. Several test problems with highly nonlinear performance functions are used to demonstrate the accuracy of the proposed method.

The seismic reliability analysis of complex structure is carried out based on the response surface method and finite element method. Firstly, the appropriate design points are selected based on the mean values and standard deviations of the basic random variables. Secondly, the finite element method is employed to obtain the values of the limit state function of the complex structure. Thirdly, with selected design points and the obtained values of the limit state function of the complex structure, a polynomial function is constructed to approximate the original implicit limit state function. Then, with the established explicit polynomial limit state function and available methods of structural reliability analysis, the seismic reliability of the complex structure is estimated. Numerical analyses show that the established method is simple to use for the evaluation of the reliability analysis of complex structure.

A new bivariate dimension reduction method for efficient structural reliability analysis

PurposeBecause of the high computational efficiency, response surface method (RSM) has been widely used in structural reliability analysis. However, for a highly nonlinear limit state function (LSF), the approximate accuracy of the failure probability mainly depends on the design point, and the result is that the response surface function composed of initial experimental points rarely fits the LSF exactly. The inaccurate design points usually cause some errors in the traditional RSM. The purpose of this paper is to present a hybrid method combining adaptive moving experimental points strategy and RSM, describing a new response surface using downhill simplex algorithm (DSA-RSM).Design/methodology/approachIn DSA-RSM, the operation mechanism principle of the basic DSA, in which local descending vectors are automatically generated, was studied. Then, the search strategy of the basic DSA was changed and the RSM approximate model was reconstructed by combining the direct search advantage of DSA with the reliability mechanism of response surface analysis.FindingsThe computational power of the proposed method is demonstrated by solving four structural reliability problems, including the actual engineering problem of a car collision. Compared to specific structural reliability analysis methods, the approach of modified DSA interpolation response surface for structural reliability has a good convergent capability and computational accuracy.Originality/valueThis paper proposes a new RSM technology based on proxy model to complete the reliability analysis. The originality of this paper is to present an improved RSM that adjusts the position of the experimental points judiciously by using the DSA principle to make the fitted response surface closer to the actual limit state surface.

복합재료가 신재생 에너지 산업 관련 구조물 및 해양 구조물에서 좀 더 신뢰도 있는 주 하중 부재로 사용되기 위하여 복합재료평판의 확률론적 비선형 초기 파단 하중과 원공과 곡률이 있는 복합재료판의 확률론적 비선형 좌굴 하중이 평가되었다. 주어진 설계 추출점에서의 확정론적 유한요소해석 결과를 바탕으로 반응면기법을 이용하여 한계상태면을 확률변수로 이루어진 2차 다항식으로 근사하였다. 또한, MPFP 근처에서 좀 더 정확하게 한계상태면을 근사하기 위하여 반복적 선형보간법이 적용되었다. 파괴확률을 평가하기 위하여 근사된 한계상태면 상에서 향상된 일계이차모멘트법과 몬테카를로법이 수행되었다. 마지막으로 파단에 영향을 주는 주요한 확률변수를 파악하기 위하여 변환된 확률변수에 대한 신뢰도지수의 감도를 계산하였다. Probabilistic nonlinear first ply failure loads of flat composite panels and nonlinear buckling loads of curved composite panels with cutouts are estimated to provide the more reliable main load carrying structure in the renewable energy industry and offshore structures. The response surface method approximates limit state surface to a second order polynomial form of random variables with the results of deterministic finite element analyses at given sampling design points. Furthermore, the iterative linear interpolation scheme is used to obtain a more accurate approximation of the limit state surface near the most probable failure point (MPFP). The advanced first order second moment method and the Monte Carlo method are performed on an approximated limit state surface to evaluate the probability of failure. Finally, the sensitivity of the reliability index with respect to transformed random variables is investigated to figure out the main random variables that have an effect on failures.

Efficient response surface method for high-dimensional structural reliability analysis

The possibility of applying the measure of information uncertainty (entropy) in structural reliability analysis of electricity distribution networks is assessed. The essential factors influencing the process of reliability analysis and related to the presence of information uncertainty are highlighted. The peculiarities of reliability analysis in network designing and operation, when it is required to estimate the state of elements and choose the efficient structure of a network are considered. The opportunities and limitations in the application of existing methods of structural reliability analysis are evaluated; it proves the importance of information uncertainty measurement. The conceptual apparatus of entropy includes the mathematical procedure of its calculation. Fail-safe operation probability and probability of network element failure are taken as reliability index. The mathematical expressions proposed for calculating entropy are applicable when there are two independently functioning network elements, each of which will be able to be in one of two states with a fraction of probability: operable and non-operable. The obtained results allowed identifying the more reliable elements/objects. The application of the proposed mathematical procedure allows to compare network elements with each other through the value of entropy and to choose the most reliable ones. Thus, the proposed solution is a preliminary step in the uncertainty removal task.

A response-surface-based structural reliability analysis method by using non-probability convex model

The importance sampling method is an extensively used numerical simulation method in reliability analysis. In this paper, a modification to the importance sampling method (ISM) is proposed, and the modified ISM divides the sample set of input variables into different subsets based on the contributive weight of the importance sample defined in this paper and the maximum super-sphere denoted by β-sphere in the safe domain defined by the truncated ISM. By this proposed modification, only samples with large contributive weight and locating outside of the β-sphere need to call the limit state function. This amelioration remarkably reduces the number of limit state function evaluations required in the simulation procedure, and it doesn’t sacrifice the precision of the results by controlling the level of relative error. Based on this modified ISM and the space-partition idea in variance-based sensitivity analysis, the global reliability sensitivity indices can be estimated as byproducts, which is especially useful for reliability-based design optimization. This process of estimating the global reliability sensitivity indices only needs the sample points used in reliability analysis and is independent of the dimensionality of input variables. A roof truss structure and a composite cantilever beam structure are analyzed by the modified ISM. The results demonstrate the efficiency, accuracy, and robustness of the proposed method.

The surrogate model-based sampling method has been an active area of research due to its evident efficiency over direct sampling method. The fusion of the adaptive kriging (AK) model with the adaptive radial-based importance sampling (ARBIS) method is developed as an improvement of the AK model combined with Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) method especially for estimating the small failure probabilities. In the AK–ARBIS method, the number of candidate samples in each updating process of the kriging model is reduced through partitioning the whole MCS sample domain into different subdomains and removing the samples inside the last subdomain from the participating candidate sampling pool, which can avoid the time-consuming matrix operation involved in kriging predictions in order to find the best training sample in each updating step. In the existing AK–ARBIS method, kriging model stops updating according to the learning function-based stopping criterion, which cannot directly reflect the error of the estimated failure probability. In this regard, this paper proposes the error-based stopping criterion (ESC) enhanced AK–ARBIS method, where the processes of finding the optimal hypersphere and accurately identifying the sign of candidate samples are decoupled in order to successfully embed the ESC. In addition to embedding the ESC into the AK–ARBIS method, two target-oriented candidate sampling reduction strategies are investigated, respectively, to improve the efficiency of finding the optimal hypersphere and accurately identifying the sign of the participating candidate samples. Based on the candidate sampling pool reduction strategies and ESC, both the computational time and the required number of calls to the real limit state function are reduced over the existing AK–ARBIS method. Three case studies are analyzed to demonstrate the accuracy and efficiency of the proposed enhanced AK–ARBIS method, especially for estimating the small failure probabilities.

The hypercone method for structural reliability analysis: Its theoretical principles

In the reliability analysis of safety critical complex engineering structures, a very large number of the system parameters can be considered as random variables. The difficulty in computing the failure probability using the classical first- and second-order reliability methods (FORM and SORM) increases rapidly with the number of variables or ‘dimension’. There are mainly two reasons behind this. The first is the increase in computational time with the increase in the number of random variables. In principle, this problem can be handled with superior computational tools. The second reason, which is perhaps more fundamental, is that there are some conceptual difficulties typically associated with high dimensions. This means that even when one manages to carry out the necessary computations, the application of existing FORM and SORM may still lead to incorrect results in high dimensions. This paper is aimed at addressing this issue. Based on the asymptotic distribution of quadratic form in Gaussian random variables, two formulations for the case when the number of random variables n →∞ is provided. The first is called ‘strict asymptotic formulation’ and the second is called ‘weak asymptotic formulation’. Both approximations result in simple closed-form expressions for the probability of failure of an engineering structure. The proposed asymptotic approximations are compared with existing approximations and Monte Carlo simulations using numerical examples.