• Cite Icon1
  • https://doi.org/10.1353/ppp.2006.0007Copy DOI Icon

Chaos and Clinical Theory

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

Chaos and Clinical Theory Douglas W. Heinrichs (bio) In considering the specific issues raised by these three very thoughtful commentaries, it is helpful to reflect on the status of a theory or model for a specifically clinical discipline—what is it trying to accomplish and how might it proceed to do so? Kellert (2005) sees my proposal in terms of "borrowed knowledge"—the metaphorical application of a theory established in one field of inquiry to another field—and views my application of chaos theory as a "nonliteral use of knowledge from the natural sciences" (p. 239). He likens it to attempts to explore consequences of relativity theory or quantum mechanics for areas other than those for which they were developed. He notes the rhetorical functions—including appeal to the disciplinary prestige of natural science—of such metaphorical borrowings. Although clearly there are significant metaphorical aspects at work here, there are at least two factors that distinguish this model from, say, the metaphorical application of quantum mechanics to a field other than subatomic physics. First, quantum mechanics purports to say something specific about the behavior of the subatomic world. Its development is wed to that specific content area. On the other hand, nonlinear dynamics, including chaos theory, is a formal mathematical model intending to characterize the behavior of any system of elements that possess certain formal relational properties. It does not start out as field or discipline specific. In fact it is not uniquely tied to the natural sciences at all, beyond the fact that it may be easier to obtain the sort of detailed repeated measures needed to demonstrate chaotic behavior in physical systems. So it is not just a question of whether chaos theory is a useful intuitive device for thinking freshly about clinical psychiatry. Rather, it is the quite literal and nonmetaphorical question as to whether some of the observable aspects of persons that are relevant to their psychiatric care behave chaotically, and if so what are the implications. Now it is quite true that direct, mathematically rigorous demonstrations of chaos in clinically relevant data sets is currently limited. In fact, one hoped for consequence of presenting this model is to encourage just such studies, and I suggest several promising directions for doing so. However, there are good reasons for thinking the presence of such chaotic behavior to be likely, and this relates to the notion of a clinical theory. One of the consequences of what Globus (2005) calls "triumphalist biological psychiatry" (p. 229) is the frequent assumption that the model or paradigm of psychiatry—an applied clinical practice, a techne—is synonymous with the paradigm of neuroscience—a basic science or episteme. This is clearly not so for many reasons, including the fact that the former has to incorporate the comprehensive treatment of discrete individuals in a way that the latter does not. Yet the respective theories are related more than metaphorically. [End Page 243] The paradigms of neuroscience and those of other relevant basic sciences, such as psychology, substantially inform the clinical paradigm and the clinical model must be at least compatible with those of the relevant basic sciences. Thus, it is reasonable to assume that if chaotic processes are demonstrable in the nervous system, for which significant evidence already exists, there is good reason to expect them to be reflected in clinically relevant domains. The clinical paradigm should make room for it and its consequences, rather than thinking within an outmoded neuroscience model that makes no room for the implications of nonlinear dynamics. And when this generates a picture more compatible than the old model with our usual sense of what it is to be human, the odds that we are on to something is further enhanced. Of course until such time that enough clinical research based on this model is completed, considerable speculation—indeed aided by metaphorical devices—is involved in generating a concrete sense of how the model would be applied to specific clinical problems, such as the treatment of depressed persons. One clear task of the clinical paradigm is the methodologic integration of interventions growing out of different informing basic sciences. Because chaotic modeling can be applied across various content domains and...

Similar Papers
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations3

The theory of dynamic chaos in the socio-philosophical and social studies

  • Apr 22, 2019
  • Науково-теоретичний альманах "Грані"
  • Anna Seliverstova
  • Research Article

Fractals in Our Mind: Chaos Theory in Psychiatry

  • Oct 14, 2017
  • American Journal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience
  • Ocrain P Radu +2
  • Conference Article
  • Citations2

Extending chaos and complexity theory to address life, brain and quantum foundations

  • Jan 01, 2000
  • P.J Werbos
  • Conference Article
  • Citations1

Application of Chaos theory in creative graphic design

  • Aug 01, 2011
  • Shouming Chen
  • PDF
  • Research Article

Putin and Chaos (How Chaos Theory is Interpreted in the Kremlin)

  • Dec 30, 2021
  • Visnyk V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University. Series "Sociological studies of contemporary society: methodology, theory, methods"
  • Ihor Rushchenko +1
  • Conference Article

Quantum Mechanics, Nonlinear Dynamics, and Correlated Statistical Mechanics

  • Jan 01, 2007
  • AIP conference proceedings
  • Wm C Mcharris
  • Research Article
  • Citations19

Does chaos theory have major implications for philosophy of medicine?

  • Dec 01, 2002
  • Medical Humanities
  • S Holm
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations39

Forecasting of landslide displacements using a chaos theory based wavelet analysis-Volterra filter model

  • Dec 01, 2019
  • Scientific Reports
  • Yuanyao Li +5
  • Book Chapter
  • Citations1

Application of Chaos Theory, Thermodynamics and AI in the Analysis of the Behavior of Complex Systems

  • Nov 01, 2022
  • Bahram Ismailov
  • Research Article

The response of an OEM to supply chain disruptions: application of Chaos Theory

  • Jan 01, 2022
  • IFAC PapersOnLine
  • Sofia Mota +1
  • Book Chapter

Chaos Theory and Fractals in Finance

  • Jan 01, 2024
  • Raisa Gulati
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Application of Chaos Theory in Incomplete Randomized Financial Analysis

  • Jan 05, 2019
  • International Journal of Economics, Finance and Management Sciences
  • Xuelin Xian +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations90

Integration and timing of basic and clinical sciences education

  • Feb 27, 2013
  • Medical Teacher
  • Glen Bandiera +4
  • Conference Article
  • Citations1

Prevention and management of congestion for next generation IP over WDM optical networks using chaos theory

  • Jan 01, 2008
  • R Mariappan
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Education research and the natural sciences: What can be learned from chaos theory?

  • Aug 01, 1993
  • The Australian Educational Researcher
  • Michael Arnold
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.