- Research Article
7
- 10.1016/s0022-4049(02)00123-8
Writing certain commutators as products of cubes in free groups
- Oct 29, 2002
- Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra
- Mehri Akhavan-Malayeri
Writing certain commutators as products of cubes in free groups
Groups are often described as quotient groups of free groups: G ≅F(X)/N, where F(X) is a free group with basis X and N is the normal subgroup generated by a set R in F(X). Usually, this will then be written as G = , where R ⊂ X+ is a set of so-called relators, standing for the defining relations {r = 1∣r ∈ R}, where 1 is the neutral element of G. All defining relations can be presented in this form, since the relation u = υ can obviously be transformed into uυ-1 = 1. For a more detailed exposition and for group theory notation as used here and in Chap. 5 see [188, 193]. For example is a presentation of the infinite cyclic group ℤ, which we will write or just for short.
Writing certain commutators as products of cubes in free groups
Writing certain commutators as products of cubes in free groups
Advanced Group Theory
This chapter continues the development of group theory begun in Chapter IV, the main topics being the use of generators and relations, representation theory for finite groups, and group extensions. Representation theory uses linear algebra and inner-product spaces in an essential way, and a structure-theory theorem for finite groups is obtained as a consequence. Group extensions introduce the subject of cohomology of groups.Sections 1–3 concern generators and relations. The context for generators and relations is that of a free group on the set of generators, and the relations indicate passage to a quotient of this free group by a normal subgroup. Section 1 constructs free groups in terms of words built from an alphabet and shows that free groups are characterized by a certain universal mapping property. This universal mapping property implies that any group may be defined by generators and relations. Computations with free groups are aided by the fact that two reduced words yield the same element of a free group if and only if the reduced words are identical. Section 2 obtains the Nielsen-Schreier Theorem that subgroups of free groups are free. Section 3 enlarges the construction of free groups to the notion of the free product of an arbitrary set of groups. Free product is what coproduct is for the category of groups; free groups themselves may be regarded as free products of copies of the integers.Sections 4–5 introduce representation theory for finite groups and give an example of an important application whose statement lies outside representation theory. Section 4 contains various results giving an analysis of the space C(G, ?) of all complex-valued functions on a finite group G. In this analysis those functions that are constant on conjugacy classes are shown to be linear combinations of the characters of the irreducible representations. Section 5 proves Burnside’s Theorem as an application of this theory—that any finite group of order paqb with p and q prime and with a+b > 1 has a nontrivial normal subgroup.Section 6 introduces cohomology of groups in connection with group extensions. If N is to be a normal subgroup of G and Q is to be isomorphic to G/N, the first question is to parametrize the possibilities for G up to isomorphism. A second question is to parametrize the possibilities for G if G is to be a semidirect product of N and Q.
Read moreLyndon's Group is Conjugately Residually Free
Lyndon's group FZ[x] is the free exponential group over the ring of integral polynomials Z[x]. This group, introduced by Lyndon in the 1960s, continues to be of interest to group theorists due to its importance in the study of first-order properties of free groups, in particular, equations over free groups. One of the crucial results of Lyndon's study was that the group FZ[x] is fully residually F; i.e. for any finite collection of nontrivial elements in FZ[x] there exists a homomorphism φ : FZ[x] → F which is the identity on F and maps the given elements of FZ[x] into nontrivial elements of F. The importance of FZ[x] was further emphasized when Kharlampovich and Myasnikov proved in [3] that a finitely generated group is fully residually free if and only if it is embeddable into FZ[x]. Lyndon's group and its subgroups play a vital role in the technique employed by O. Kharlampovich and A. Myasnikov in their solution of the famous Tarski problem on the decidability of the elementary theory of a free group (see [4, 5]). In this paper, we show that Lyndon's group is conjugately residually free, i.e. it is possible to map FZ[x] to the free group F preserving the nonconjugacy of two elements. This result is a further step towards the understanding of the properties of FZ[x]; moreover, it is closely related to the problem of "lifting solutions" of equations from F to FZ[x], since our result implies that the solutions can indeed be "lifted" from F to FZ[x] for equations of the type x-1 c1 x = c2. The structure of Lyndon's group, described by A. Myasnikov and V. Remeslennikov in [8], involves an infinite sequence of free constructions of a specific type, called free extensions of centralizers. For more results on residual properties of certain types of free constructions, see also the works of Ribes, Segal and Zalesskii (for example [9]).
Read moreSchur rings over infinite dihedral group
Schur rings over the infinite dihedral group Z ⋊ Z 2 are studied according to properties of Schur rings over infinite groups and the classification of Schur rings over infinite cyclic groups. Schur rings over Z ⋊ Z 2 are classified under the assumption that Z is an A -subgroup. Those Schur rings are proved to be traditional.
Read morePointwise inner automorphisms in a free nilpotent group
An automorphism θ of a group G is pointwise inner if θ (t) is conjugate to t for any t ∈ G. It is known that in a free group, each pointwise inner automorphism is inner. We prove that this property remains true in a free nilpotent group. In fact, more generally, an automorphism of a non‐cyclic free group fixing each normal subgroup is inner. We show that in a non‐abelian free nilpotent group of class c, this last property is true if c = 2, but false if c > 2.
Read moreGrowth series of crossed and two-sided crossed products of cyclic groups
We recall that the two-sided crossed product of finite cyclic groups is actually a generalization of the crossed product construction of the same type of groups (cf. [10]). In this paper, by considering the crossed and two-sided crossed products obtained from both finite and infinite cyclic groups, we first present the complete rewriting systems and normal forms of elements over crossed products. (We should note that the complete rewriting systems and normal forms of elements over two-sided crossed products have been recently defined in [10]). In the crossed product case, we will consider their presentations that were given in [2]. As a next step, by using the normal forms of elements of these two products, we calculate the growth series of the crossed product of different combinations of finite and infinite cyclic groups as well as the growth series of two-sided crossed product of finite cyclic groups.
Read moreSystematization of dimensionless quantities by group theory
Systematization of dimensionless quantities by group theory
The fundamental group of a surface, and a theorem of Schreier
Schreier proved in [8] tha t a finitely generated normal subgroup U # { 1 } of a free group F is of finite index. This result was extended by Karrass and Solitar in [3], to the case when U is not necessarily normal, but contains a non-trivial normal subgroup of F. In Topology, the free groups occur as fundamental groups of surfaces with boundary, and we here extend the result still further (Theorem 6.1) to the case when F is the (non-abelian) fundamental group of any connected surface, with or without boundary, except for a Klein bottle. We use topological methods, and also the elements of Morse theory, although the latter could be ehminated. A sketch of this theory is included, however, par t ly for its intuitive appeal, and part ly because the Morse theory picks out stable generators of the fundamental group, and therefore is helpful as a tool. Indeed, the author was able to use it quickly to prove Schreier's Theorem, and Theorem 3.3 below (that an open surface has free fundamental group), before knowing tha t proofs already existed in the literature. Our exposition is always from the point of view tha t it is the surface, ra ther than the group, which is the ult imate object o f study; and we have perhaps laboured points tha t might irk the pure group-theorist.
Read moreOn the computational complexity of the theory of Abelian groups
On the computational complexity of the theory of Abelian groups
Coherence, subgroup separability, and metacyclic structures for a class of cyclically presented groups
Coherence, subgroup separability, and metacyclic structures for a class of cyclically presented groups
On the SQ-Universality of HNN Groups
A group G is S-universal if every countable group can be embedded in a quotient of G.In this paper we give conditions under which HNN groups are S-universal.These are then applied to showing the S-universality of certain classes of Kleinian groups (discontinuous subgroups of PSL^C)).Finally some connections are mentioned between Sg-universality and the theory of ends.Introduction.A group G is So-universal if every countable group can be embedded in a quotient of G. Thus all nonabelian free groups are Suniversal [4], while it is known that all nontrivial free products except the infinite dihedral group [10], and large classes of amalgamated free products are also , [11].Sacerdote and Schupp have extended these to certain HNN and one-relator groups [9].In this paper we give a series of results which complement those of Sacerdote and Schupp but are somewhat less technical and more directly applicable to geometrically and arithmetically defined groups [2], [3].This will be applied in 3 to showing the S?-universality of a class of Kleinian groups.Finally we make some observations on the relationship between SG;-universality and the theory of ends.1. Recall that an HNN group is a group of the form G = </" ...,t",K; rel K, t^tr1 = <P,(A)>where {L,} are subgroups of K, and {<p,} are isomorphisms L, - <p,(jL,) < K. K is called the base, {L, <p(L)} associated subgroups and </" . .., i") the free part.Groups of this type were used by Higman, Neumann and Neumann to show the S-universality of free groups of rank 2 [4].The base K can be embedded isomorphically in G, and a subgroup structure theory for HNN groups, paralleling that for amalgamated free products, has been developedby Karrass and Solitar [5].Now G has a free quotient of rank n if the free part has rank n, and since clearly a group with an S-universal quotient is itself S-universal we getLemma.An HNN group with free part of rank > 1 is SQ-universal.
Read moreOn monoids, $$2$$ 2 -firs, and semifirs
Several authors have studied the question of when the monoid ring \(DM\) of a monoid \(M\) over a ring \(D\) is a right and/or left fir (free ideal ring), a semifir, or a \(2\)-fir (definitions recalled in §1). It is known that for \(M\) nontrivial, a necessary condition for any of these properties to hold is that \(D\) be a division ring. Under that assumption, necessary and sufficient conditions on \(M\) are known for \(DM\) to be a right or left fir, and various conditions on \(M\) have been proved necessary or sufficient for \(DM\) to be a \(2\)-fir or semifir. A sufficient condition for \(DM\) to be a semifir is that \(M\) be a direct limit of monoids which are free products of free monoids and free groups. Warren Dicks has conjectured that this is also necessary. However F. Cedó has given an example of a monoid \(M\) which is not such a direct limit, but satisfies all the known necessary conditions for \(DM\) to be a semifir. It is an open question whether for this \(M,\) the rings \(DM\) are semifirs. We note here some reformulations of the known necessary conditions for a monoid ring \(DM\) to be a \(2\)-fir or a semifir, motivate Cedó’s construction and a variant thereof, and recover Cedó’s results for both constructions. Any homomorphism from a monoid \(M\) into \(\mathbb {Z}\) induces a \(\mathbb {Z}\)-grading on \(DM,\) and we show that for the two monoids just mentioned, the rings \(DM\) are “homogeneous semifirs” with respect to all such nontrivial \(\mathbb {Z}\)-gradings; i.e., have (roughly) the property that every finitely generated homogeneous one-sided ideal is free of unique rank. If \(M\) is a monoid such that \(DM\) is an \(n\)-fir, and \(N\) a “well-behaved” submonoid of \(M,\) we prove some properties of the ring \(DN.\) Using these, we show that for \(M\) a monoid such that \(DM\) is a \(2\)-fir, mutual commutativity is an equivalence relation on nonidentity elements of \(M,\) and each equivalence class, together with the identity element, is a directed union of infinite cyclic groups or of infinite cyclic monoids. Several open questions are noted.
Read moreHomology in varieties of groups. IV
The study of homology groups ${\mathfrak {B}_n}(\Pi ,A),\mathfrak {B}$ a variety, $\Pi$ a group in $\mathfrak {B}$, and $A$ a suitable $\Pi$-module, is continued. A âTorâ is constructed which gives a better (but imperfect) approximation to these groups than a Tor previously considered. ${\mathfrak {B}_2}(\Pi ,Z)$ is calculated for various varieties $\mathfrak {B}$ and groups $\Pi$.
Read moreErratum to Integrality of L2-Betti numbers
A gap has been found in the proof of Proposition 3 of [3]. Consequently, this result and the consequences drawn in the paper have to be considered as conjectures. In particular, it is not proved that the Atiyah conjecture is stable under extensions with free quotient groups and under free products with free groups..
Read moreRibbonness of a stable-ribbon surface-link, I. A stably trivial surface-link
Ribbonness of a stable-ribbon surface-link, I. A stably trivial surface-link