Improvement approaches and performance of temperature-based remote sensing evapotranspiration models in agricultural fields: A meta analysis

According to 230 flux site observations, intra-day and diurnal ground heat flux (G) accounted for 19.2 % and 28.8 % of the corresponding net radiation, respectively. This indicates that G plays an important role in remote sensing (RS) evapotranspiration (ET) models. The accuracy of the five G simulation methods in the surface energy balance-based RS ET models was evaluated using half-hourly observations. The linear coefficient (LC) method and the methods embedded with the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) were able to accurately simulate a half-hourly G series at most sites. The mean and median Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) values of all sites were generally higher than 0.50 in each half-hour period. However, the two methods embedded by fractional vegetation coverage showed poor performance in most half-hour periods, except the sunrise and sunset periods, with the mean and median NSE values of all sites below 0.20. The accuracy of each method varied significantly at different sites and at half-hour intervals. The highest accuracy was exhibited during sunrise periods (6:00–7:00), followed by sunset periods (17:00–18:00). There were 92 % (211/230) sites with an NSE of the LC method greater than 0.50 at 6:30. It showed a slightly higher accuracy during night periods than during daytime periods. The lowest accuracy was observed at noon periods (10:00–15:30). The sites with an NSE exceeding 0.50 only accounted for 51 % (118/230) and 43 % (100/230) at 10:30 and 13:30, respectively. The accuracy of Northern Hemisphere sites was generally higher than that of Southern Hemisphere sites. In general, the highest and lowest accuracies were observed at the high- and low-latitude sites, respectively. The performance of the LC method and the methods embedded with NDVI were generally satisfactory at the Eurasian and North American sites, with the NSE values of most sites exceeding 0.70. Conversely, it exhibited relatively poor performance at the African, South American, and Oceanian sites, especially the African sites. Both the temporal and spatial distributions of the accuracy of the G simulation were positively correlated with the correlation between G and the net radiation. Although the G simulation methods accurately simulated the G series at most sites and time periods, their performance was poor at some sites and time periods. The application of RS ET datasets covering these sites requires caution. The optimal parameter value for each method varied greatly at different sites. This indicates that the fixed parameter values in the G simulation methods are not appropriate. Further improvement of G simulations at these sites and time periods is recommended for the RS ET modelers.

Cropland evapotranspiration (ET) is the major source of water consumption in agricultural systems. The precise management of agricultural ET helps optimize water resource usage in arid and semiarid regions and requires field-scale ET data support. Due to the combined limitations of satellite sensors and ET mechanisms, the current high-resolution ET models need further refinement to meet the demands of field-scale ET management. In this research, we proposed a new field-scale ET estimation method by developing an allocation factor to quantify field-level ET variations and allocate coarse ET to the field scale. By regarding the agricultural field as the object of the ET parcel, the allocation factor is calculated with combined high-resolution remote sensing indexes indicating the field-level ET variations under different crop growth and land-surface water conditions. The allocation ET results are validated at two ground observation stations and show improved accuracy compared with that of the original coarse data. This allocated ET model provides reasonable spatial results of field-level ET and is adequate for precise agricultural ET management. This allocation method provides new insight into calculating field-level ET from coarse ET datasets and meets the demands of wide application for controlling regional water consumption, supporting the ET management theory in addressing the impacts of water scarcity on social and economic developments.

Evapotranspiration (ET) is dynamic and influences water resource distribution. Sustainable management of water resources requires accurate estimations of the individual components that result in evapotranspiration, including the daily net radiation (DNR). Daily ET is more useful than the evaporative fraction (EF) provided by remote sensing ET models, and to account for daily variations, EF is usually combined with the DNR. DNR exhibits diurnal and spatiotemporal variations due to landscape heterogeneity. In the modified Two-Source Energy Balance (TSEB) approach by Zhuang and Wu, 2015, ecophysiological constraint functions of temperature and moisture of plants based on atmospheric moisture and vegetation indices were introduced, but the DNR was not spatially accounted for in the estimation of the daily ET. This research adopted a novel approach that accounts for spatiotemporal variations in estimated daily ET by incorporating the Bisht and Bras DNR model in the modified version of the TSEB model. Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer (ASTER) satellite imagery over the Tono irrigation watershed within the Upper East Region of Ghana and Southern Burkina Faso were used. We estimated the energy fluxes of latent and sensible heat as well as the net radiation and soil heat fluxes from the satellite images and compared our results with ground-based measurements from an eddy covariance (EC) station established by the West African Science Service Center on Climate Change and Adapted Land Use (WASCAL) within the watershed area. We noticed a similarity between our model estimated fluxes and ET with the ground-based EC station measurements. Eight different land use/cover types were identified in the study area, and each of these contributed significantly to the overall ET variations between the two study periods: December 2009 and December 2017. For instance, due to a higher leaf area index (LAI) for all vegetation types in December 2009 than in December 2017, the ET for December 2017 was higher than that for December 2009. We also noticed that the land use/cover types within the footprint area of the EC station were only six out of the eight. Generally, all the surface energy fluxes increased from December 2009 to December 2017. Mean ET varied from 3.576 to 4.486 (mm/d) for December 2009 while from 4.502 to 5.280 (mm/d) for December 2017 across the different land use/cover classes. Knowledge of the dynamics of evapotranspiration and adoption of cost-effective methods to estimate its individual components in an effective and efficient way is critical to water resources management. Our findings provide a tool for all water stakeholders within watersheds to manage water resources in an engaging and cost-effective way.

Large sample datasets of in situ evapotranspiration (ET) measurements with well documented data provenance and quality assurance are critical for water management and many fields of earth science research. We present a post-processed ET oriented dataset at daily and monthly timesteps, from 161 stations, including 148 eddy covariance flux towers, that were chosen based on their data quality from nearly 350 stations across the contiguous United States. In addition to ET, the data includes energy and heat fluxes, meteorological measurements, and reference ET downloaded from gridMET for each flux station. Data processing techniques were conducted in a reproducible manner using open-source software. Most data initially came from the public AmeriFlux network, however, several different networks (e.g., the USDA-Agricultural Research Service) and university partners provided data that was not yet public. Initial half-hourly energy balance data were gap-filled and aggregated to daily frequency, and turbulent fluxes were corrected for energy balance closure error using the FLUXNET2015/ONEFlux energy balance ratio approach. Metadata, diagnostics of energy balance, and interactive graphs of time series data are included for each station. Although the dataset was developed primarily to benchmark satellite-based remote sensing ET models of the OpenET initiative, there are many other potential uses, such as validation for a range of regional hydrologic and atmospheric models.

Rational utilization of water resources is one of the major methods of water conservation. There are significant differences in the irrigation needs of different agricultural fields because of their spatial variability. Therefore, a decision support system for variable rate irrigation (DSS-VRI) by center pivot was developed. This system can process multi-spectral images taken by unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) and obtain the vegetation index (VI). The crop evapotranspiration model (ETc) and crop water stress index (CWSI) were obtained from their established relationships with the VIs. The inputs to the fuzzy inference system were constituted with ETc, CWSI and precipitation. To provide guidance for users, the duty-cycle control map was outputted using ambiguity resolution. The control command contained in the map adjusted the duty cycle of the solenoid valve, and then changed the irrigation amount. A water stress experiment was designed to verify the rationality of the DSS-VRI. The results showed that the more severe water stress is, the more irrigation is obtained, consistent with the expected results. Meanwhile, a user-friendly software interface was developed to implement the DSS-VRI function.

Remotely sensed canopy resistance model for analyzing the stomatal behavior of environmentally-stressed winter wheat