• Home
  • Search
  • Methodology and framework of comparative urban planning law
  • Cite Icon7
  • https://doi.org/10.1108/jppel-12-2022-0037Copy DOI Icon

Methodology and framework of comparative urban planning law

  • Abstract
  • PDF
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

PurposeThis study aims to systematise the methodology used in comparative urban planning law and propose primary contexts for comparison in planning law.Design/methodology/approachThis study undertook a review of comparative law methodology discourse and sought to establish connections between the discourse and the field of planning law.FindingsThis study argues for establishment of a realistic goal for comparative planning law by focusing on the planning law's modifiability. The goal of comparison in planning law should not be to find universally desirable principles or better solutions. Rather, the goal should be to identify a motive for devising a solution. This is because it is not only difficult to establish legal values that are universally applicable to planning law but also inappropriate to determine superiority of planning laws that have been developed over time by each jurisdiction’s sovereignty and policies on land use. When determining comparable systems for analysis among legal systems that are functionally equivalent, it is important to consider the context of land use relations alongside the comparative analysis to be done. To set realistic goals, the context should not be extended indefinitely but be systematised. Based on the foundational relationship underlying planning law, including the tension between planning authorities and property owners, this study presents five specific contexts for comparative analysis: “Strength of Property Rights,” “Level of Judicial Intervention,” “Plan- or Development-led System,” “Allocation of Planning Power” and “Level of Participation.” Examination of these contexts will allow better understanding of the similarities and differences among different systems and practical application of the results of comparative studies.Originality/valueThis study presents a novel approach to systematising the methodology and framework of comparative planning law.

Loading PDF

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations44

Quality and the Commons: The Surf Gangs of California

  • Nov 01, 2009
  • The Journal of Law and Economics
  • Daniel T Kaffine
  • Research Article
  • Citations47

Why It Is Difficult to Change Urban Planning Laws in African Countries

  • Jun 14, 2011
  • Urban Forum
  • Stephen Berrisford
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Urban planning law in the face of the Olympic challenge: Between innovation and criticism of exceptional urban regeneration

  • Jun 01, 2023
  • Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit
  • Geneviève Zembri-Mary +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations84

Weak Property Rights and Holdup in R&D

  • Dec 01, 2000
  • Journal of Economics & Management Strategy
  • Bharat N Anand +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations98

Liberalism and Married Women’s Property Rights in Nineteenth-Century Latin America

  • Nov 01, 2005
  • Hispanic American Historical Review
  • Carmen Diana Deere +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations3

The Particulars of Owning

  • Dec 01, 1999
  • Ecology Law Quarterly
  • Eric T Freyfogle
  • Research Article

Some Aspects of Planning Law in England

  • Jan 01, 1957
  • The University of Toronto Law Journal
  • J F Garner
  • Research Article
  • Citations14

The Essential Structure of Property Law

  • Jan 01, 2017
  • Michigan Law Review
  • James Stern
  • Research Article

Compensation Due To Lower Community Land Ownership Status In Batam

  • Feb 20, 2024
  • Syiah Kuala Law Journal
  • Lia Nuraini +3
  • Research Article

The Colour of Copyright

  • Jul 01, 2002
  • M/C Journal
  • Margaret Mcdonnell
  • Research Article
  • Citations6

The New Chinese Property Rights Law: An Evaluation from a Continental Perspective

  • Jun 23, 2019
  • Columbia Journal of Asian Law
  • Gebhard M Rehm +1
  • Research Article

Впровадження досвіду Німеччини для вдосконалення ведення земельного кадастру в Україні

  • Sep 01, 2025
  • Modern achievements of geodesic science and industry
  • Yu Hubar +2
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

General Provisions of Intellectual Property Rights in Ukraine

  • Nov 17, 2023
  • Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
  • I.I Komarnytska +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations5

A comprehensive review of the impact of farmland property rights stability on farmers' land use and protection behaviors

  • Apr 17, 2024
  • Land Degradation & Development
  • Xie Baopeng +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations7

Whose future, whose security?: Unconventional oil and gas extraction and the economic vulnerability and forced participation of small-scale property owners

  • Sep 28, 2023
  • Resources policy
  • Stephanie A Malin +2
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.