Near Optimal and Energy-Efficient Scheduling for Hard Real-Time Embedded Systems

Energy consumption has become a major constraint in providing increased functionality for devices with small form factors. Dynamic voltage and frequency scaling has been identified as an effective approach for reducing the energy consumption of embedded systems. Earlier works on dynamic voltage scaling focused mainly on performing voltage scaling when the CPU is waiting for memory subsystem or concentrated chiefly on loop nests and/or subroutine calls having sufficient number of dynamic instructions. This paper concentrates on coarser program regions and for the first time uses program phase behavior for performing dynamic voltage scaling. Program phases are annotated at compile time with mode switch instructions. Further, we relate the Dynamic Voltage Scaling Problem to the Multiple Choice Knapsack Problem, and use well known heuristics to solve it efficiently. Also, we develop a simple integer linear program formulation for this problem. Experimental evaluation on a set of media applications reveal that our heuristic method obtains a 38% reduction in energy consumption on an average, with a performance degradation of 1% and upto 45% reduction in energy with a performance degradation of 5%. Further, the energy consumed by the heuristic solution is within 1% of the optimal solution obtained from the ILP approach.KeywordsExecution TimeSupply VoltageKnapsack ProblemBasic BlockProgram RegionThese keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Shrinking feature sizes, reduced voltages, and higher transistor count of nano-scale silicon chips challenge designers in terms of performance, power consumption, and reliability. This paper investigates the effect of simultaneous use of dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS) and body biasing (BB) on power consumption, reliability, and performance. An analytical model of reliability as a function of body bias voltage, supply voltage, and frequency is proposed. We derive a three dimensional optimization problem by exploiting proposed reliability model in conjunction with power consumption and performance model. The resulting problem is solved using widely-used geometric optimization to identify optimal supply voltage and body bias voltage and then is validated using accurate simulation. Afterwards, it is demonstrated how joint energy-performance-reliability space optimization method can be used in an adaptive reliability-aware power management systems. Finally, we show that combined soft error aware BB and DVFS is capable of improving power consumption about 30% in comparison to reliability-aware DVFS only for the same level of reliability and performance constraints.

The functionality of embedded systems is ever growing. The computational power of embedded systems is growing to match this demand, with embedded multiprocessor systems becoming more common. The limitations of embedded systems are not always related to chip size but are commonly due to energy and/or power constraints. While it can be possible to embed a more powerful Multiprocessor System on Chip (MPSoC), it is not always possible to provide an energy or power supply that meets its demands within the device’s size and weight requirements. Power management through Dynamic Voltage and Frequency Scaling (DVFS) enables the device to be run at less than its maximum voltage and frequency, allowing high computational capability when necessary while conserving power at other times. Embedded systems commonly perform real-time functionality. A real-time application has an associated formal model to verify that it meets its timing requirements. This formal model is used to perform a worst-case timing analysis to ensure that the application meets its requirements. These models incorporate the worst-case timing of the application’s computation and communication. Timing changes due to power management must also be taken into account, complicating the verification process. The drive for evermore functionality has led to mixed time-criticality systems, in which multiple applications of various timing criticalities share the same (hardware) resources. This complicates the verification process further as the timing interference due to shared resource contention must be taken into account. A monolithic verification effort is therefore traditionally required after system integration and must be carried out again if any modifications are made that affect the timing of any of the applications. The problem that we aim to solve in this work is to enable real-time applications to perform independent execution and power management without violating their timing requirements or invalidating the timing verification of concurrently executing applications. To solve this problem, we contribute the Composable and Predictable Microkernel (CoMik) to composably and predictably virtualise processors. When used in combination with composable and predictable memory controllers and interconnect (as provided by the Composable and Predictable System-on-Chip (CompSOC) platform), these virtual processors cannot interfere with each other’s timing by even a single cycle. If whatever executes on the virtual processors (e.g. an Operating System (OS) or an application directly) has a real-time requirement, it can be verified independently of whatever executes on the concurrent virtual processors and other virtual resources. To enable formally analysable application execution, we contribute the Predictable Operating System (POSe) that enables dataflow applications to be executed on the (virtualised) processor. We contribute a combined application and platform dataflow graph, including an algorithm to automate this process. When annotated with worst-case timings, the combined application and system graph is then used to verify that the application meets its timing requirement. If the application’s performance is better than its requirement (e.g. when the input or platform behaviour are better than worst case), its performance can be reduced using DVFS to achieve a reduction in power consumption. We contribute an off-line convex optimisation that uses the combined application and platform dataflow model to derive static run-time operating frequency levels to achieve low power consumption. The off-line technique is able to exploit static slack in the schedule, but not dynamic run-time slack due to variations in task execution times. Before dynamic slack can be used it must be possible to observe it. For this purpose, CoMik provides independent power, energy and timing accounting per virtual processor. This enables each virtual processor to be assigned individual power and energy budgets and POSe applications to be assigned timing budgets. We contribute a description and model of how energy and power budgets can be distributed between multiple virtual processors, enabling whatever executes on the virtual processor to perform composable independent power-management without affecting the ability of other virtual processors from using their entire budget allocation. Using CoMik’s accounting infrastructure, we also demonstrate how the quality of applications can be dynamically scaled to assist meeting timing, energy or power requirements. We further contribute a distributed dynamic power management policy that enables dataflow applications that are mapped onto multiple (virtual) processors to make distributed dynamic slack observations and local power-management decisions. We demonstrate the applicability of the presented techniques on an implemented Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) prototype of a CompSOC hardware platform instance, using an H.263 decoder as a case-study application. We show that our techniques do not only work in theory, but that they are also implementable and implemented.

Recent research has shown that the combination of dynamic voltage scaling (DVS) and adaptive body biasing (ABB) yields high energy reductions in embedded systems. Nevertheless, the implementation of DVS and ABB requires a significant system cost, making it less attractive for many small systems. In this paper we demonstrate that it is possible to reduce this system cost and to achieve comparable energy saving to that obtained using combined DVS and ABB scheme through a co-synthesis methodology which is aware of the tasks' power-composition profile (the ratio of the dynamic power to the leakage power). In particular, the presented methodology performs a power management selection at the architectural level, i. e., it decides upon which processing elements to be equipped with which power management scheme (DVS, ABB, or combined DVS and ABB) - with the aim to achieve high energy savings at a reduced implementation cost. The proposed technique maps, schedules, and voltage scales applications specified as task graphs with timing constraints. Detailed experiments including a real-life benchmark are conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed methodology.

As the computing environments are continuously moving towards battery-operated mobile and handheld systems, the development of energy-saving mechanisms for such devices has recently become a technical challenge. Dynamic voltage scaling (DVS) has historically been considered an effective method to reduce the processor power consumption. Conventional DVS techniques typically consider only processor utilisation issues in a policy-making process. However, as memory-bound multimedia applications are becoming popular in handheld devices, the DVS policies should consider the so-called ‘memory wall’ problem to maximise energy gain. Recent DVS techniques suffer from the inefficiency of their policies caused by the memory-wall problem while executing multimedia applications, and no previous research on DVS considers the problem explicitly. The existence of the memory wall problem in a real system is revealed and a metric that can be used to detect the problem in advance is found. A memory-aware DVS (M-DVS) technique that takes the memory wall problem fully into consideration is proposed. The experimental results on a PDA show that M-DVS can reduce ∼8% of additional power consumption, compared with conventional DVS, without any QoS degradation for handling multimedia clips.

Dynamic voltage scaling (DVS) provides power savings for systems with varying performance requirements. One low overhead implementation of DVS uses PMOS power switches to connect DVS blocks to one of the available VDD supplies. While power switches have been analyzed extensively for leakage power gating, proper design of power switches for DVS is less well understood. This paper characterizes power switches for DVS in terms of VDD-switching delay and VDD-switching energy. We show the impact of these switching overheads on a novel fine-grained DVS architecture and present an RC model that allows fast estimation of the overhead. Measurements of a DVS multiplier and adder on a 90 nm CMOS test chip validate the model. Our model and measurements confirm that power switched DVS can provide sufficiently low overhead to give energy savings with only one clock cycle spent at a lower voltage, making this approach a flexible and enticing option for embedded portable systems.

Reduction of power dissipations in CMOS circuits needs to be addressed for portable battery devices. Selection of appropriate transistor library to minimise leakage current, implementation of low power design architectures, power management implementation, and the choice of chip packaging, all have impact on power dissipation and are important considerations in design and implementation of integrated circuits for low power applications. Energy-efficient architecture is highly desirable for battery operated systems, which operates in a wide variation of operating scenarios. Energy-efficient design aims to reconfigure its own architectures to scale down energy consumption depending upon the throughput and quality requirement. An energy efficient system should be able to decide its minimum power requirements by dynamically scaling its own operating frequency, supply voltage or the threshold voltage according to a variety of operating scenarios. The increasing product demand for application specific integrated circuit or processor for independent portable devices has influenced designers to implement dedicated processors with ultra low power requirements. One of these dedicated processors is a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) processor, which is widely used in signal processing for numerous applications such as, wireless telecommunication and biomedical applications where the demand for extended battery life is extremely high. This paper presents the design and performance analysis of a low power shared memory FFT processor incorporating dynamic voltage scaling. Dynamic voltage scaling enables power supply scaling into various supply voltage levels. The concept behind the proposed solution is that if the speed of the main logic core can be adjusted according to input load or amount of processor's computation "just enough" to meet the requirement. The design was implemented using 0.12 μm ST-Microelectronic 6-metal layer CMOS dual- process technology in Cadence Analogue Environment.

We present a dynamic voltage and frequency scaling technique within SoCs for per-core power management: the architecture allows for individual, self triggered performance-level scaling of the processing elements (PEs) within less than 100ns. This technique enables each core to adjust its local supply voltage and frequency depending on its current computational load. A test chip has been implemented in 28nm CMOS technology, as prototype of the SpiNNaker2 neuromorphic many core system, containing 4 PEs which are operational within the range of 1.1V down to 0.7V at frequencies from 666MHz down to 100MHz; the effectiveness of the power management technique is demonstrated using a standard benchmark from the application domain. The particular domain area of this application specific processor is real-time neuromorphics. Using a standard benchmark - the synfire chain - we show that the total power consumption can be reduced by 45%, with 85% baseline power reduction and a 30% reduction of energy per neuron and synapse computation, all while maintaining biological real-time operation.

Modern real-time embedded systems have increasingly penetrated our daily life and are also often constrained in terms of temperature and energy. In this paper, a thesis is defended that from a real-time systems perspective, thermally constrained dynamic power management approaches behave very similar to idealised dynamic voltage and frequency scaling. Hence, existing dynamic voltage and frequency scaling solutions proposed for periodic/sporadic task models can be applied to thermally constrained dynamic power management systems with moderate effort. This work presents the similarities along with the distinctive elements between two approaches. Within the case study, the porting of a dynamic voltage and frequency scaling algorithm of the literature to thermally constrained dynamic power management system is demonstrated.

Slack computation for DVS algorithms in fixed-priority real-time systems using fluid slack analysis

Dynamic voltage scaling (DVS) is a powerful technique to reduce power dissipation in embedded systems. Some efficient DVS algorithms have been recently proposed for the energy reduction in distributed system. However, they achieve the energy savings solely by scaling the system task with respect to the timing constraints, while neglecting that power varies among, the tasks executed by DVS processing elements (DVS-PEs). In this paper we investigate the problem of considering DVS-PE power variations dependent on the executed tasks, during the synthesis of distributed embedded systems and its impact on the energy savings. Unlike previous approaches, which minimise the energy consumption by exploiting the available slack time without considering the PE power profiles, a new and fast heuristic for the voltage scaling problem is proposed, which improves the voltage selection for each task dependent on the individual power dissipation caused by that task. Experimental results show that energy reductions with up to 80.7% are achieved by integrating the proposed DVS algorithm, which considers the PE power profiles, into the co-synthesis of distributed systems.

Dynamic voltage scaling (DVS) reduces the power consumption of processors when peak performance is unnecessary. However, the achievable power saving by DVS alone is becoming limited as leakage power increases. In this paper, we show how the simultaneous use of adaptive body biasing (ABB) and DVS can be used to reduce power in high-performance processors. Analytical models of the leakage current, dynamic power, and frequency as functions of supply voltage and body bias are derived and verified with SPICE simulation. We then show how to determine the correct trade-off between supply voltage and body bias for a given clock frequency and duration of operation. The usefulness of our approach is evaluated on real workloads obtained using real-time monitoring of processor utilization for four applications. The results demonstrate that application of simultaneous DVS and ABB results in an average energy reduction of 48% over DVS alone.

Along with the prevailing of mobile devices, the demand for efficient power consumption has become one of the major issues in designing embedded system. Dynamic Voltage Scaling (DVS) is a technique that can reduce energy consumption by changing the processor voltage levels dynamically. Fixed Priority with Preemption Threshold (FPPT) scheduling is a scheduling policy that includes preemptive and non-preemptive aspect of scheduling policy. In this paper, an efficient universal fixed priority DVS algorithm (FPPT-DVS) will be presented. This algorithm has the advantage of both Fixed Priority Preemptive (FPP) DVS scheduling and Fixed Priority Non-Preemptive (FPNP) DVS scheduling. FPPT-DVS algorithm also combines the on-line DVS and off-line DVS together. Experimental results show that the proposed FPPT-DVS algorithm can save up to 20% energy over the existing DVS algorithms.

Numerous Dynamic Voltage Scaling (DVS) methods have been proposed over the years, and since several commercial programmable processors supporting DVS are now available, the demand for DVS evaluation tools is obvious. In this paper we propose a simulator based on soft- and hardware parameters that make it possible to get realistic performance evaluations from a high abstraction level. Traditionally, DVS methods have been tested using unrealistic assumptions, both from a software and hardware point of view, but this problem is now alleviated due to our simulator. We show that DVS methods are very depended on the application specification as well as the processor parameters.

For real time applications, time slacks of a preliminary task schedule may be exploited to conserve energy. This can be accomplished by leveraging the dynamic voltage scaling (DVS) technique to slow down clock frequency of certain cores as long as the deadline is met. In this chapter, the task of fine-tuning an existing task assignment and schedule and using DVS to lower the overall energy consumption is formulated as a graph-theoretic maximum weight clique (MWC) problem. An efficient heuristic algorithm is proposed to systematically solve this problem. A unique feature of our approach is concurrently applying DVS to slow down the execution of multiple tasks to achieve better energy savings. Extensive simulations are performed to compare this proposed algorithm against leading energy-aware task scheduling algorithm and DVS algorithm. Our algorithm exhibits 22% more energy savings than the Energy Aware Scheduling (EAS) algorithm. As for energy saving in DVS process, our MWC-based method provides a 97% saving improvement over the PV-DVS algorithm.