- Research Article
1
- 10.1093/ml/64.3-4.225
THE DURANTE/‘PERGOLESI’ MAGNIFICAT: A NEW SOURCE
- Jan 01, 1983
- Music and Letters
- Jno L Hunt
NEXT to Vivaldi's Gloria and Pergolesi's Stabat Mater, the four-part Magnificat in B flat by Francesco Durante is among the most familiar pieces of eighteenthcentury Italian sacred music. Its deserved popularity, however, has been achieved on Pergolesi's shoulders, for it is under his name that it is commonly known today. Surprisingly, in view of its wide currency, the misattribution is neither of long standing nor based on any but the flimsiest evidence. The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries knew the Magnificat as a work by Durante.' It was ascribed to Pergolesi only in 1910, by Giuseppe Radiciotti,2 on the strength of a single manuscript copy that bears Pergolesi's name in what is now the Biblioteca Civica in Bergamo and in the face of 21 other manuscript sources that bear Durante's. In 1942, presumably on the basis of Radiciotti's influential monograph, it was included by Filippo Caffarelli in his notoriously unreliable edition of Pergolesi's works.3 True, the attribution to Pergolesi has never been accepted in the scholarly world. But the inclusion of the Magnificat in the hallowed surroundings of a collected edition, however unreliable, has established a popular myth that remains stubbornly persistent.4 If there were ever any serious doubt about the authorship of the Magnificat, the matter is surely settled by the existence of an autograph score in Durante's hand in Naples, Biblioteca del Conservatorio, Rari 1.6.19. Unlike all other manuscript sources (and all printed editions), however, the Naples score is for five voices, not four, having an extra soprano part. There are other instances of works by Durante surviving in two different versions.5 In direct parallel with the Magnificat, a four-part Te Deum in Naples, Conservatorio, MR 489, is found with an additional soprano part in Paris, Bibliotheque Nationale, D 3646-2, and in London, British Library, Add. MS 14107. The same British Library manuscript includes a four-part 'Laudate pueri Dominum', also found in Naples, Conservatorio, MR 450, which exists in an eight-part version in Paris, Bibliotheque Nationale, D 3647-2. The fifth voice affects the texture of the Magnificat in various ways. At the first entry of the tutti in the opening movement, after the initial intonation of the Magnificat tone on which the work is based, the two soprano parts are used to
Read more