- Research Article
76
- 10.2139/ssrn.871037
Optimal Monetary and Fiscal Policy in a Currency Union
- Jan 01, 2005
- SSRN Electronic Journal
- Tommaso Monacelli + 1 more +1
Optimal Monetary and Fiscal Policy in a Currency Union
We study optimal monetary policy in an economy with nominal private debt, borrowing constraints and price rigidity. Private debt reflects equilibrium trade between an impatient borrower, who faces an endogenous collateral constraint, and a patient saver, who engages in consumption smoothing. Since inflation can positively affect borrower's net worth, monetary policy optimally balances the incentive to offset the price stickiness distortion with the one of marginally relaxing the borrower's collateral constraint. We find that the optimal volatility of inflation is increasing in three key parameters: (i) the borrower's weight in the planner's objective function; (ii) the borrower's impatience rate; (iii) the degree of price flexibility. In general, however, deviations from price stability are small for a small degree of price stickiness. In a two-sector version of our model, in which durable price movements can directly affect the ability of borrowing, the optimal volatility of (non-durable) inflation is more sizeable. In our context, and relative to simple Taylor rules, the Ramsey-optimal allocation entails a partial smoothing of real durable goods prices.
Optimal Monetary and Fiscal Policy in a Currency Union
Optimal Monetary and Fiscal Policy in a Currency Union
A New Dilemma: Capital Controls and Monetary Policy in Sudden-Stop Economies
A New Dilemma: Capital Controls and Monetary Policy in Sudden-Stop Economies
Banking Competition, Collateral Constraints, and Optimal Monetary Policy
We analyze optimal monetary policy in a model with two distinct financial frictions: monopolistically competitive banks that charge endogenous lending spreads, and collateral constraints. We show that welfare maximization is equivalent to stabilization of four goals: inflation, output gap, the “consumption gap” between borrowers and savers, and a “housing gap” that measures the distortion in the distribution of the collateralizable asset between both groups. Collateral constraints create a trade‐off between stabilization goals. Following both productivity and financial shocks, and relative to strict inflation targeting, the optimal policy implies sharper movements in the policy rate, aimed primarily at reducing fluctuations in asset prices and hence in borrowers' net worth. The policy trade‐offs become amplified as banking competition increases, due to the fall in lending spreads and the resulting increase in borrowers' leverage.
Read moreBorrowing constraint, heterogeneous production sectors and policy implications: The case of China
Borrowing constraint, heterogeneous production sectors and policy implications: The case of China
RAMSEY MONETARY POLICY WITH CAPITAL ACCUMULATION AND NOMINAL RIGIDITIES
Recent literature on the design of optimal monetary policy has shown that deviations from price stability are small whenever prices are sticky. This paper reconsiders this issue by introducing capital accumulation in the model. Optimal monetary policy in this setup implies small deviations from price stability. The monetary authority optimally uses inflation as an explicit tax on monopolistic profits to reduce the price markup across states. Variable markup is achieved in this setup because the share of investment demand over output varies across states and in response to TFP shocks.
Read moreMonetary Policy For Maintaining Low, Stable Inflation In Malaysia
The main thesis of this paper is that low, stable inflation, implying price stability, is important for promoting and sustaining economic growth in the midst of shocks of both domestic and foreign origin. The paper makes an overview of inflation, inflation volatility and monetary policy in Malaysia since the late 1950s and provides some evidence for a link between inflation volatility and economic growth. As part of determining the appropriate strategy of monetary policy for price stability, the paper investigates some monetary relations—namely the stability of the money-demand function and the linkages among money, output and prices—which form the foundation of a money-based monetary policy strategy under a flexible exchange rate system. The empirical results suggest that the narrow money-demand function in Malaysia remained stable over the period 1971–2012 and that cointegral-causal linkages existed in this country among money, output and prices throughout this period. These results give credence to deployment of monetary aggregates as an instrument of monetary policy, especially when the flexibility, effectiveness of a zero-bound interest rate remains doubtful as an instrument of monetary policy in a low-inflation environment. Nevertheless, Malaysia has apparently taken the stance that money does not matter insofar as inflation and its volatility are concerned. The money growth rate has remained volatile in this country and contributed to high and volatile inflation for most of the time over the study period. Some empirical results suggest that despite the impression of rule-based monetary strategy, Malaysia did not conduct a rule-based monetary policy—within either monetary targeting or inflation targeting—to keep inflation low and stable. Instead, the Bank Negara Malaysia (central bank of Malaysia) used discretionary monetary policy to achieve multiple objectives, including rapid economic growth. An outcome of this policy was elevated inflation volatility, which affected real interest and exchange rates and raised output volatility. The paper concludes that improved monetary policy transparency and elevated monetary policy credibility are expected to make a rule-based monetary policy more effective and keep inflation low and stable.
Read moreCyclical Inequality in the Cost of Living and Implications for Monetary Policy
This paper documents that households with higher marginal propensities to consume (MPCs) tend to consume goods with more flexible prices. Consequently, they face more cyclical and volatile inflation and experience higher inflation following an expansionary monetary policy shock. We embed this MPC-price stickiness relationship into a tractable multi-sector Two-Agent New Keynesian (TANK) model and analytically demonstrate that it dampens the effectiveness of monetary policy, reducing its efficacy by about 15% relative to a benchmark model with homogeneous consumption baskets. Introducing heterogeneous baskets also generates an inherently inefficient flexible-price equilibrium, which gives rise to a novel trade-off between stabilization and redistribution. The optimal monetary policy therefore differs qualitatively from the standard TANK policy prescription.
Read moreCan We Still Lean Against the Wind?
In an overlapping generations model without financial frictions, Gali (Am Econ Rev 104(3):721–752, 2014) observed that a ‘leaning against the wind’ monetary policy is likely to aggravate the fluctuations in the bubble. He found that optimal monetary policy in such an economy must strike a balance between stabilization of the bubble and stabilization of aggregate demand. This paper extends Gali (Am Econ Rev 104(3):721–752, 2014)’s model by introducing various financial frictions in the bubbly economy with a Samuelson 2-period overlapping agents and examine how ‘leaning against the wind’ macro-prudential policies like capital adequacy affect the size and volatility of bubble, inflation and aggregate demand. While the results of the model with financial frictions vindicate Gali (Am Econ Rev 104(3):721–752, 2014) that a leaning against the wind monetary policy generates a larger volatility in the bubble than a policy of benign neglect, the paper finds that minimisation of bubble volatility requires an active macro-prudential policy. It is also observed that stronger interest rate response of monetary policy to the bubble necessitates a stronger macroprudential response possibly to absorb the excess volatility generated by the monetary policy. However, the paper also finds that tightening macroprudential policy parameter beyond a threshold value may encourage banks to take more risks and increase credit supply, aggravating the bubble in the process. With respect to macroprudential policy, there is no conflict between stabilization of current aggregate demand and stabilization of future aggregate demand and both call for a strong macroprudential response, at least until the macroprudential parameter attains the threshold value, although the conflict between the two objectives persists with respect to monetary policy as in Gali (Am Econ Rev 104(3):721–752, 2014). Empirical verification of the provisioning cost channel through structural vector autoregression confirm that a positive provisions shock can contract asset bubbles by restricting credit, output and a delayed marginal response of interest rate spreads.
Read moreEssays on Monetary and Macro-prudential Policy in a DSGE Model with Banking Sector
The thesis is composed of three chapters which analyze the monetary and macro-prudential policy using a New Keynesian DSGE model with the banking sector. The first chapter evaluates the effectiveness of time-varying macro-prudential tools and their interaction with monetary policy using the model framework of Gertler and Karadi (2011) which emphasizes the role of bank capital and endogenous leverage constraint due to the moral hazard problem. We consider the following three types of countercyclical macro-prudential tools: (i) capital requirements (CAR), (ii) deposit-based reserve requirements (DBRR), and (iii) asset-based reserve requirements (ABRR). The main findings are as follows. First, all three types of macro-prudential policy tools reacting to the financial condition (credit to output gap) are effective to mitigate the fluctuation of credit and business cycle by weakening the pro-cyclicality of banks' net worth and the counter-cyclicality of the endogenous leverage and external finance premium. Second, the effectiveness of each instrument differs by the source of shocks to the economy. In response to a TFP shock, the counter-cyclical CAR is the most effective to mitigate the fluctuation of credit and output and the ABRR is relatively more effective in response to capital quality shocks (credit supply shock). Third, all types of macro-prudential tools are welfare improving in combination with monetary policy, but the use of macro-prudential policy is relevant in response to the credit supply shock (financial shock). Finally, when the economy is hit by a financial shock, a relatively direct tool like asset-based reserve requirement (ABRR) can be the most welfare-improving and the relationship between monetary and macro-prudential policy can be complementary each other. The second chapter examines the role of banks' endogenous reserves and capital and the usefulness of financial condition (credit aggregates and external finance premium) as an indicator for setting up a relevant monetary policy rule. For the task, I construct an extended version of Goodfriend and McCallum (2007) model which is characterized by banks' loan production function with inputs (collaterals, monitoring works and bank capital buffer) under the households' deposit in advance (DIA) constraint. Main findings are as follows. First, banks' endogenous reserves can mitigate the variation of external finance premium by substituting costly monitoring works for lending. However, the effect of endogenous reserves on output and credits depends on types of shocks (credit-demand vs credit-supply shock), which reflects the role of external finance premium (EFP) as a banking attenuator (pro-cyclical EFP) or financial accelerator (counter-cyclical EFP) respectively. Second, the effect of banks' endogenous reserves can be limited when banks can adjust their capital flexibly compared to when banks' keep their capital to asset ratio (leverage) stable. Third, considering the role of money and the frictions on the credit-supply side, monetary policy reacting actively to the financial condition is welfare improving. These results imply that quantitative easing (QE) policy during the crisis was effective but the effectiveness of QE can be limited when banks can lower their leverage in a pro-cyclical manner. And monetary policy should pay more attention to the financial condition and prevailing interest rates as well as inflation and output gap in the presence of substantive financial frictions on the credit supply side in particular when the banking shocks dominate the economy. In the last chapter (co-authored with Professor Jagjit S. Chadha), we investigate the question facing many emerging economies: the extent to which a workhorse advanced economy model can yield important insights for monetary policy-making. We note that the standard sticky-price, monopolistically competitive model does not allow analysis of money and credit dynamics and led to a concentration of research on simple interest rate reaction functions. However, time-varying financial frictions tend to act as a tax on intermediation activities and so can vary output in a significant manner. In this chapter, we consider the implications of financial frictions for baseline monetary policy using a model calibrated on Indian data and find that a simple interest rate reaction function may not be welfare maximizing when banking shocks are dominant in the economy.
Read moreEditorial Announcement
The first eight papers in this issue constitute a Symposium on Optimal Monetary Policy. A call for papers on this topic was published in the July 2000 issue of the Review. There we asked for papers on the theoretical analysis of optimal monetary stabilization policy, in the context of models of the real effects of monetary policy with explicit microeconomic foundations. The proposed topic of the symposium attracted considerable interest, and we received 29 submissions, from among which these eight papers were accepted for publication. All submitted papers were refereed and subjected to the usual editorial standards of the Review. The final two papers in this issue were not submitted in response to the call for papers for the symposium, but are other papers submitted to the journal that are of some relevance to the theme of this issue.
Read moreOptimal Interest Rate Policy in a Small Open Economy
Using an optimizing model we derive the optimal monetary and exchange rate policy for a small stochastic open economy with imperfect competition and short run price rigidity. The optimal monetary policy has an exact closed-form solution and is obtained using the utility function of the representative home agent as welfare criterion. The optimal policy depends on the source of stochastic disturbances affecting the economy, much as in the literature pioneered by Optimal monetary policy reacts to domestic and foreign disturbances. If the intertemporal elasticity of substitution in consumption is less than one, as is likely to be the case empirically, the optimal exchange rate policy implies a dirty float: interest rate shocks from abroad are met partially by adjusting home interest rates, and partially by allowing the exchange rate to move. This optimal pattern may help rationalize the observed fear of floating.
Read moreJointly Optimal Monetary and Fiscal Policy Rules Under Borrowing Constraints
We study the welfare properties of an economy where both monetary and fiscal policy follow simple rules, and where a subset of agents is borrowing constrained. The optimized fiscal rule is far more aggressive than automatic stabilizers, and stabilizes the income of borrowingconstrained agents, rather than output. The optimized monetary rule features super-inertia and a very low coefficient on inflation, which minimizes real wage volatility. The welfare gains of optimizing the fiscal rule are far larger than the welfare gains of optimizing the monetary rule. The preferred fiscal instruments are government spending and transfers targeted to borrowing-constrained agents
Read moreFinancial globalization and monetary policy
Financial globalization and monetary policy
The stickiness of colombian consumer prices
En este articulo se estudia la formacion de precios de los minoristas de bienes y servicios colombianos con base en 12.052.970 reportes de precios de los articulos que conforman el IPC colombiano para el periodo de 1999.03 a 2008.05. Los principales resultados se resumen asi: (1) los precios al consumidor de Colombia son mas rigidos que los de Chile y Portugal y podrian ser mas flexibles que los del Eurozona. (2) Cuarenta por ciento de los cambios en los precios son reducciones (3) los cambios absolutos en los precios son mayor que la inflacion (4) cuando la inflacion se reduce en Colombia: la rigidez de los precios se incrementa, la variabilidad y sesgo de la distribucion de los cambios en los precios disminuye y las rigideces nominales a la baja en la frecuencia de los cambios en precios es invariante a la inflacion (5) se encontro una ligera rigidez a la baja (6) la sincronizacion de los cambios en los precios es baja (7) cerca del 32% del IPC corresponde a contratos de Taylor, 34% a otras reglas dependientes del tiempo y 34% a reglas dependientes del estado. Estos resultados proveen algunos fundamentales microeconomicos para el diseno de la politica monetaria.
Read moreOptimal monetary policy in an estimated SIR model
Optimal monetary policy in an estimated SIR model