Real-time single-frequency precise point positioning: accuracy assessment

Single-frequency (SF) receivers are much cheaper than that of dual-frequency (DF). Even though DF precise point positioning (PPP) is nowadays applied in the time community, the cost of equipment is one of the key considerations for time users. Furthermore, the hardware delay calibration of single-frequency devices is simpler than that of dual-frequency devices. In addition, there is no literature to study real-time SF PPP time transfer. In this contribution, the possibility of time transfer using SF PPP was studied. The Un-combined SF PPP was employed for time transfer with ionospheric-constraint using real-time precise products. In this case, 18 multi-GNSS experiment (MGEX) stations and one time lab station were used to study real-time SF PPP time transfer using GPS, Galileo and BDS-2/3 satellites with 20-day. The results suggested that real-time single-frequency PPP can meet time transfer. the standard deviation (STD) of the clock difference obtained from GPS-only, Galileo-only and BDS-2/3 single-frequency PPP are about (0.51, 0.54, 0.91) ns, respectively. The frequency stability of real-time single-frequency PPP can achieve (1E-12, 1E-13, 1E-13) level at short-term and (1E-13, 1E-13, 1E-14) level at long-term, respectively, for BDS-2/3, Galileo-only and GPS-only based.

ABSTRACT: Precise Point Positioning (PPP) has received increased interest within the GPS community for a number of reasons: simplified field operation, cost-effectiveness, and no base station requirement. PPP with dual-frequency receivers and precise GPS products has demonstrated centimeter to decimeter positioning accuracy. Using real-time precise GPS products, this accuracy is also obtainable in a real-time mode. This paper investigates PPP using single-frequency GPS data which will be of interest to a broad range of applications because the majority of GPS users are using single-frequency GPS receivers. Since the ionospheric effect will be the biggest error source for single-frequency receiver based precise point positioning, different methods for ionospheric effect mitigation will be assessed and compared so that sub-meter positioning accuracy becomes obtainable.

One of the challenges in the innovative application of global navigation satellite systems (GNSS) lies in real-time single-frequency precise point positioning (RT-SFPPP). The well-known problems associated with SFPPP are its slow convergence and lower positioning accuracy due to the effects of various errors inherited by the GNSS positioning, including the atmospheric error. In order to mitigate the two above-mentioned problems, several scenarios for the reduction of the atmospheric delays in RT-SFPPP, including the ionospheric constraint and tropospheric constraint, were investigated in this research. The performance of the RT-SFPPP utilizing the above-mentioned methods was evaluated using one-week observations from multi-GNSS experiment stations in a simulated kinematic mode. Results showed that the convergence time of the RT-SFPPP was significantly shortened when the slant ionospheric delays derived from the real-time ionospheric products provided by Centre National d’Études Spatiales were applied as the pseudo-observations. Results also showed that the convergence time of GPS + GLONASS RT-SFPPP can be reduced by modeling the frequency-dependent part of the GLONASS receiver uncalibrated code delay as a quadratic polynomial function of GLONASS frequency number. The a priori zenith wet delays (ZWDs) derived from forecast Vienna Mapping Functions 3 (VMF3_FC) were compared to the reference ZWDs from globally distributed radiosonde stations. The mean root mean square error of the a priori ZWDs resulting from VMF3_FC at 381 radiosonde stations in 2020 was 1.53 cm compared to the radiosonde-based ZWDs. When the ZWDs derived from VMF3_FC were used as pseudo-observations in the position estimation system, the convergence time for the vertical positioning reaching a 0.3 m accuracy was considerably shortened.

Precise Point Positioning (PPP) is a popular technology for precise applications based on the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS). Multi-GNSS combined PPP has become a hot topic in recent years with the development of multiple GNSSs. Meanwhile, with the operation of the real-time service (RTS) of the International GNSS Service (IGS) agency that provides satellite orbit and clock corrections to broadcast ephemeris, it is possible to obtain the real-time precise products of satellite orbits and clocks and to conduct real-time PPP. In this contribution, the real-time multi-GNSS orbit and clock corrections of the CLK93 product are applied for real-time multi-GNSS PPP processing, and its orbit and clock qualities are investigated, first with a seven-day experiment by comparing them with the final multi-GNSS precise product ‘GBM’ from GFZ. Then, an experiment involving real-time PPP processing for three stations in the Multi-GNSS Experiment (MGEX) network with a testing period of two weeks is conducted in order to evaluate the convergence performance of real-time PPP in a simulated kinematic mode. The experimental result shows that real-time PPP can achieve a convergence performance of less than 15 min for an accuracy level of 20 cm. Finally, the real-time data streams from 12 globally distributed IGS/MGEX stations for one month are used to assess and validate the positioning accuracy of real-time multi-GNSS PPP. The results show that the simulated kinematic positioning accuracy achieved by real-time PPP on different stations is about 3.0 to 4.0 cm for the horizontal direction and 5.0 to 7.0 cm for the three-dimensional (3D) direction.

Performance assessment of real-time multi-GNSS integrated PPP with uncombined and ionospheric-free combined observables

The availability of raw Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) measurements from Android smart devices gives new possibilities for precise positioning solutions, e.g., Precise Point Positioning (PPP). However, the accuracy of the PPP with smart devices currently is a few meters due to the poor quality of the raw GNSS measurements in a kinematic scenario and in urban environments, particularly when the smart devices are placed inside vehicles. To promote the application of GNSS PPP for land vehicle navigation with smart devices, this contribution studies the real-time PPP with smartphones. For data quality analysis and positioning performance validation, two vehicle-based kinematic positioning tests were carried out using two Huawei Mate30 smartphones and two Huawei P40 smartphones with different installation modes: the vehicle-roof mode with smartphones mounted on the top roof outside the vehicle, and the dashboard mode with smartphones stabilized on the dashboard inside the vehicle. To realize high accuracy positioning, we proposed a real-time smartphone PPP method with the data processing strategies adapted for smart devices. Positioning results show that the real-time PPP can achieve the horizontal positioning accuracy of about 1–1.5 m in terms of root-mean-square and better than 2.5 m at the 95th percentile for the vehicle-based kinematic positioning with the experimental smartphones mounted on the dashboard inside the vehicle, which is the real scenario in vehicle navigation.

Real-Time (RT) Precise Point Positioning (PPP) uses precise satellite orbits and clock corrections, and employs a separate receiver for positioning. With the growing demand, RT PPP is becoming an increasingly popular research topic. The ambiguity resolution (AR) can significantly improve the positioning accuracy and convergence time of PPP, so it is essential to study PPPAR in RT mode. In this paper, 37 MGEX stations from around the world are chosen, and the RT orbit, clock, and phase biases products broadcast by the Centre National d’Etudes Spatiales (CNES) are applied to PPPAR. Additionally, the residuals of the RT phase biases products, convergence time, and positioning accuracy are investigated. The results indicate that GPS products have the best quality of AR, with wide-lane (WL) and narrow-lane (NL) residuals of 98.9% and 95.3%, respectively, within ±0.25 cycles. Within ±0.25 cycles, the WL and NL residuals of the Galileo are 98.2% and 94.3%, respectively. Within ±0.25 cycles, the (Beidou Navigation Satellite System) BDS has a poor quality of AR, with WL and NL residuals of 97.3% and 73.1%, respectively. Due to the poor quality of the BDS AR, the convergence time of the BDS is not calculated in this paper. The convergence time of other systems is significantly reduced after AR processing, and the convergence time of the GPS/Galileo combination is the fastest, being 17.14 min in kinematic mode and only 11.85 min in static mode. The positioning accuracy of the GPS, Galileo, GPS/Galileo, and GPS/Galileo/BDS in the E and U directions is significantly improved after PPPAR.

For time-critical precise applications, one popular technology is the real-time precise point positioning (PPP). In recent years, there has been a rapid development in the BeiDou Navigation Satellite System (BDS), and the constellation of global BDS (BDS-3) has been fully deployed. In addition to the regional BDS (BDS-2) constellation, the real-time stream CLK93 has started to support the BDS-3 constellation, indicating that the real-time PPP processing involving BDS-3 observations is feasible. In this study, the global positioning performance of real-time PPP with BDS-3/BDS-2 observations is initially evaluated using the datasets from 147 stations. In the east, north and upward directions, positioning accuracy of 1.8, 1.2 and 2.5 cm in the static mode, and of 6.7, 5.1 and 10.4 cm in the kinematic mode can be achieved for the BDS-3/BDS-2 real-time PPP, respectively, while the corresponding convergence time with a threshold of 10 cm is 32.9, 23.7 and 32.8 min, and 66.9, 42.9 and 69.1 min in the two modes in the three directions, respectively. To complete this, the availability of BDS-3/BDS-2 constellations, the quality of BDS-3/BDS-2 real-time precise satellite products, and the BDS-3/BDS-2 post-processed PPP solutions are also analyzed. For comparison, the results for the GPS are also presented.

Satellite orbit error and clock bias are the keys to precise point positioning (PPP). The traditional PPP algorithm requires precise satellite products based on worldwide permanent reference stations. Such an algorithm requires considerable work and hardly achieves real-time performance. However, real-time positioning service will be the dominant mode in the future. IGS is providing such an operational service (RTS) and there are also commercial systems like Trimble RTX in operation. On the basis of the regional Continuous Operational Reference System (CORS), a real-time PPP algorithm is proposed to apply the coupling estimation of clock bias and orbit error. The projection of orbit error onto the satellite-receiver range has the same effects on positioning accuracy with clock bias. Therefore, in satellite clock estimation, part of the orbit error can be absorbed by the clock bias and the effects of residual orbit error on positioning accuracy can be weakened by the evenly distributed satellite geometry. In consideration of the simple structure of pseudorange equations and the high precision of carrier-phase equations, the clock bias estimation method coupled with orbit error is also improved. Rovers obtain PPP results by receiving broadcast ephemeris and real-time satellite clock bias coupled with orbit error. By applying the proposed algorithm, the precise orbit products provided by GNSS analysis centers are rendered no longer necessary. On the basis of previous theoretical analysis, a real-time PPP system was developed. Some experiments were then designed to verify this algorithm. Experimental results show that the newly proposed approach performs better than the traditional PPP based on International GNSS Service (IGS) real-time products. The positioning accuracies of the rovers inside and outside the network are improved by 38.8% and 36.1%, respectively. The PPP convergence speeds are improved by up to 61.4% and 65.9%. The new approach can change the traditional PPP mode because of its advantages of independence, high positioning precision, and real-time performance. It could be an alternative solution for regional positioning service before global PPP service comes into operation.

Real-time precise point positioning (PPP) has been evolved as a powerful technique to achieve globally homogenous decimeter or even centimeter positioning accuracy, which is widely used for maritime precise positioning applications. Currently, the research of the real-time PPP for maritime applications mainly focuses on GPS and GLONASS. In addition, the real-time PPP for kinematic maritime positioning is at least limited by two issues, (i) The real-time availability of the correction products for satellite orbits and clocks; (ii) The error correction related to the marine environment, especially for the estimation of wet zenith troposphere delay (ZWD) is challenged by complex fluctuations of marine atmospheric weather and the severe multipath caused by the sea clutter reflection. In this contribution, using the State-Space Representation correction products based on Radio Commission for Maritime Services (RTCM-SSR), we develop a GPS/BDS real-time kinematic maritime PPP. On the one hand, a piece-wise method is adopted to estimate the ZWD and the horizontal gradient. On the other hand, a robust sequential least squares (RSLSQ) PPP estimator is adopted based on IGG-III model to restrain the unmolded gross error. Based on the 6 h maritime data, the results show that the up direction accuracy and the convergence time of GPS, BDS and GPS/BDS, respectively, are improved based on 0.5 window length for ZWD estimation and the RSLSQ estimator. In addition, the horizontal accuracy of real-time single BDS and GPS using RTCM-SSR can achieve the accuracy of sub-decimeter level when the positioning error is convergence. Compared with the single constellation, the positioning accuracy and the convergence time of the real-time GPS/BDS using RTCM-SSR improves, respectively, by 10 and 18%, and the kinematic positioning accuracy in horizontal is better than 30 cm.

Real-time precise point positioning (PPP) is possible through the availability of the real-time satellite orbit and clock corrections to broadcast ephemeris, the real-time broadcast corrections (BCs). The real-time BCs are currently available in global as well as in regional reference frames. In this contribution, PPP usage and the performance of these global and regional BCs are analyzed for the North American Datum of 1983 (NAD83). The limitations of the current regional BC approach for NAD83 are identified and the coordinate differences it leads to compared with the traditional global BC approach are shown. Although the biases as a result of the different reference frame usage are shown to be subcentimeter, it is also shown how they can be reduced or eliminated by modifying either the PPP algorithm or the regional BC approach. Analyses were performed for three different PPP variants, a single-frequency ionosphere-free variant, a dual-frequency ionosphere-free variant, and a single-frequency ionosphere-corrected variant.

An efficient clock offset datum switching compensation method for BDS real-time satellite clock offset estimation

Real-time precise orbit and clock products are crucial for real-time high-precision precise point positioning (PPP). The key for precise orbit prediction is to precisely determine the initial conditions (satellite position, velocity at the initial epoch) and the solar radiation pressure (SRP) parameters using an arc of known precise orbits. The optimal arc length will be investigated for precise orbit prediction, with which the high-accuracy satellite clocks can be estimated. The orbit prediction accuracies with different arc lengths and conditions over time are also investigated. The results indicate that the predicted orbit accuracy is governed by the SRP parameters. In addition, the predicted orbits and estimated clocks are evaluated quantitatively with respect to PPP solutions during in and out of eclipses seasons, based on which the optimal arc length is identified. The numerical results show that high-accuracy orbital prediction can be achieved using an arc length between 36 and 48 h and generally an arc length of 42 h is considered to be optimal. With this optimal arc length, the estimated clock accuracy is 0.048 and 0.122 ns for a prediction interval of 6 and 24 h, respectively. The average PPP ambiguity fix-rates with a prediction interval of 6 h are 80.2 and 84.7 % over an observation period of 30 min and 1 h, respectively.

Abstract. PPP-RTK has been widely investigated to take the advantages of both real-time kinematic (RTK) and precise point positioning (PPP) techniques. Prior to PPP-RTK, the conventional RTK based on the use of a single base station, on the one hand, has been extended to work within a regional network of multiple base stations, known as network RTK (NRTK). The RTK and NRTK enable fast ambiguity resolution over a short baseline or a local region. PPP, on the other hand, eliminates the need to establish any local network like NRTK, which is able to work in a single receiver mode but it suffers long convergence time in ambiguity resolution. PPP-RTK therefore can provide fast ambiguity resolution capability like RTK and NRTK. Current PPP-RTK techniques however still face challenges in supporting mass-market applications such as mobile devices and autonomous vehicles. Although PPP-RTK system (a combination of RTK and PPP technologies) can help expand the coverage of RTK and speed up the ambiguity resolution in PPP, the deployment and maintenance of a dense network of permanent base stations and a central data processing infrastructure for generation of SSR corrections increases not only the system cost but also the system complexity. This is particularly an obstacle for mass-market applications. In this paper, a new RTK approach is described. First it is based on a single base station state-space-representation (SSR) correction generation strategy to support fast ambiguity resolved PPP. Further it presents a new peer-to-peer propagation strategy to form a real-time dynamically generated network of base stations to support mass-market application users with unbounded coverage. As a result, the new approach eliminates the need to deploy and maintain a dense network of permanent base stations and central data processing infrastructure as required in a conventional PP-RTK system.

Evaluation of BDS-2 real-time orbit and clock corrections from four IGS analysis centers