• Home
  • Search
  • Replication and Treatment Strength in Whole‐Lake Experiments
  • Cite Icon142
  • https://doi.org/10.2307/1937550Copy DOI Icon

Replication and Treatment Strength in Whole‐Lake Experiments

  • Apr 1, 1989
  • Ecology
  • Stephen R Carpenter
Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

Replication of large—scale experiments is desirable, but the numbers of replicates needed are not known. Costs and feasibility of ecosystem experiments depend critically on the numbers of replicates needed because of the high cost per replicate and the scarcity of experimental ecosystems. This paper examines the numbers of replicates and magnitudes of manipulation needed to detect changes in lake primary productivity resulting from piscivore manipulations. Substantial (°10 x changes in the independent variable, piscivore biomass) and sustained (at least 3—5 yr) manipulations using five reference and five experimental ecosystems produced significant t test results in >80% of simulated experiments. The need for substantial and sustained manipulations is consistent with published results of whole—lake experiments on nutrient inputs, chemical contaminants, and the biota. In many cases, limited numbers of experimental systems or high costs will prevent adequate replication of ecosystem experiment. When large—scale experiments employ insufficient (e.g., 2 or 3) replicates and/or modest perturbations of the independent variate, there is great risk of erroneously accepting the hypothesis of no treatment effect. Therefore, unreplicated paired—system experiments (one reference and one experimental system) are often preferable even though classical statistics cannot be used to determine whether manipulation caused a change in the experimental system. A series of unreplicated paired—system experiments, staggered in time and performed in many locations, will provide more ecological insight than a replicated experiment in a single region. Few statistical methods pertain to large—scale ecological experiments; innovations could be very beneficial.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations23

Recent changes in atmospheric input and primary productivity in the north Indian Ocean

  • Jul 01, 2023
  • Heliyon
  • J Kuttippurath +4
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations13

Deoxygenation dynamics on the western Nile deep-sea fan during sapropel S1 from seasonal to millennial timescales

  • May 12, 2021
  • Climate of the Past
  • Cécile L Blanchet +5
  • Research Article
  • Citations20

Weather-driven change in primary productivity explains variation in the amplitude of two herbivore population cycles in a boreal system.

  • Nov 23, 2017
  • Oecologia
  • Joshua H Schmidt +5
  • Research Article
  • Citations16

Tight benthic-pelagic coupling drives seasonal and interannual changes in iron‑sulfur cycling in Arctic fjord sediments (Kongsfjorden, Svalbard)

  • Jan 01, 2022
  • Journal of Marine Systems
  • Lisa C Herbert +7
  • Research Article
  • Citations10

Sedimentary record of primary productivity changes in a crater lake in Northeast China since the Last Glacial Maximum

  • Oct 05, 2024
  • Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology
  • Yao Wang +6
  • Research Article
  • Citations9

Recent trophic state changes of selected Florida lakes inferred from bulk sediment geochemical variables and biomarkers

  • Sep 19, 2019
  • Journal of Paleolimnology
  • T E Arnold +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations4

The effect of nutrient additions on the partitioning of nutrients in an experimental coastal Mediterranean system

  • Apr 01, 2004
  • Biogeochemistry
  • Carlos M Duarte +2
  • Conference Article
  • Citations7

Design of experimental adaptive beamforming system utilizing microphone array

  • Jan 01, 2013
  • Yuze Sun +2
  • Preprint Article

Response of the ocean carbon and oxygen cycles to climate change and anthropogenic nutrient inputs

  • May 15, 2023
  • Akitomo Yamamoto +5
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations94

Productivity changes in the Mediterranean Sea for the twenty-first century in response to changes in the regional atmospheric forcing

  • Oct 16, 2015
  • Frontiers in Marine Science
  • Diego M Macias +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations45

The response of deep-water benthic foraminiferal assemblages to changes in paleoproductivity during the Pleistocene (last 769.2 kyr), western South Atlantic Ocean

  • Sep 12, 2015
  • Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology
  • Fabiana K De Almeida +3
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations24

14,000-year Carbon Accumulation Dynamics in a Siberian Lake Reveal Catchment and Lake Productivity Changes

  • Nov 25, 2021
  • Frontiers in Earth Science
  • Lara Hughes-Allen +7
  • Conference Article

Adaptability Analysis and Evaluation of Different Water Control Measures Based on Physical Experiments

  • Apr 27, 2026
  • Zhiyuan Qi +7
  • Research Article
  • Citations41

A centennial scale organic-walled dinoflagellate cyst record of the last deglaciation in the South Adriatic Sea (Central Mediterranean)

  • Aug 08, 2002
  • Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology
  • Francesca Sangiorgi +2
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations5

Distribution Characteristics and Genesis of Marine Anoxic Conditions in the Southwest of the Upper Yangtze Basin During the Late Ordovician–Early Silurian, South China

  • Jul 04, 2022
  • Frontiers in Earth Science
  • Zaitian Dong +5
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.