Right-angled Artin groups and a generalized isomorphism problem for finitely generated subgroups of mapping class groups

We prove that, aside from the obvious exceptions, the mapping class group of a compact orientable surface is not abstractly commensurable with any right-angled Artin group. Our argument applies to various sub- groups of the mapping class group—the subgroups generated by powers of Dehn twists and the terms of the Johnson filtration—and additionally to the outer automorphism group of a free group and to certain linear groups. There are many analogies and interconnections between the theories of right- angled Artin groups on one hand and mapping class groups on the other hand. For instance, by the work of Crisp and Wiest (13), the work of Koberda (27), and the work of the first two authors with Mangahas (12), there is an abundance of injective homomorphisms from right-angled Artin groups to mapping class groups. Also, the last two authors proved (30) that any two elements of the pure braid group either generate a free group or a free abelian group—a property shared by all right-angled Artin groups (4, Theorem 1.2). We are thus led to ask to what extent mapping class groups are the same as right-angled Artin groups. It is straightforward to see that most mapping class groups are not isomorphic to right-angled Artin groups, for instance because right-angled Artin groups are torsion free. On the other hand, mapping class groups have finite-index sub- groups that are torsion free, and so this leaves open the possibility that mapping class groups are abstractly commensurable to right-angled Artin groups, that is, that they have isomorphic finite-index subgroups. We prove that, aside from a small number of exceptions, this is not the case. We also extend this result to several classes of groups related to mapping class groups. We start by recalling some definitions. To a finite graph , we can associate a right-angled Artin grou p: this is the group with one generator for each vertex of , and one defin ing relator for each edge, namely, the commutator of the two generators corresponding to the endpoints. Let Sg,n denote a closed, connected, orientable surface of genus g with n marked points. The mapping class group Mod(Sg,n) is the group of homotopy classes of orientation-preserving homeomorphisms of Sg,n preserving the set of marked points. As discussed in Koberda's paper (27, Theorem 1.5), no finite-index subgroup of Mod(Sg,n) injects into a right-angled Artin group if g ≥ 2 and (g,n) 6 (2,0); see

We construct the first known examples of nontrivial, normal, all pseudo-Anosov subgroups of mapping class groups of surfaces. Specifically, we construct such subgroups for the closed genus two surface and for the sphere with five or more punctures. Using the branched covering of the genus two surface over the sphere and results of Birman and Hilden, we prove that a reducible mapping class of the genus two surface projects to a reducible mapping class on the sphere with six punctures. The construction introduces "Brunnian" mapping classes of the sphere, which are analogous to Brunnian links.

We introduce a technique for proving quantitative representation stability theorems for sequences of representations of certain finite linear groups over a field of characteristic zero. In particular, we prove a vanishing result for higher syzygies of VIC- and SI-modules, which can be thought of as a weaker version of a regularity theorem of Church-Ellenberg in the context of FI-modules. We apply these techniques to the rational homology of congruence subgroups of mapping class groups and congruence subgroups of automorphism groups of free groups. This partially resolves a question raised by Church and Putman-Sam. We also prove new homological stability results for mapping class groups and automorphism groups of free groups with twisted coefficients.

Superinjective simplicial maps of complexes of curves and injective homomorphisms of subgroups of mapping class groups

Let Γg,b denote the orientation-preserving mapping class group of a closed orientable surface of genus g with b punctures. For a group G let Φf(G) denote the intersection of all maximal subgroups of finite index in G. Motivated by a question of Ivanov as to whether Φf(G) is nilpotent when G is a finitely generated subgroup of Γg,b, in this paper we compute Φf(G) for certain subgroups of Γg,b. In particular, we answer Ivanov’s question in the affirmative for these subgroups of Γg,b.

This is an expanded version of a conference lecture on groups ΓΣF of the form $$1 \to {\pi _1}\sum \to {\Gamma _{\sum , }}F \to F \to 1$$ where Σ is a closed, oriented surface of genus ≥ 2 and F is a free subgroup of rank ≥ 2 in the mapping class group MCG(Σ) = Out(π1Σ). In joint work with Benson Farb [FM01], [FM00a]we characterize when ΓΣF is word hyperbolic, and when it is, we prove that ΓΣF is quasi-isometrically rigid in a very strong sense.

This chapter deals with Dehn twists, the simplest infinite-order elements of Mod(S). It first defines Dehn twists and proves that they are nontrivial elements of the mapping class group. In particular, it considers the action of Dehn twists on simple closed curves. As one application of this study, the chapter proves that if two simple closed curves in Sɡ have geometric intersection number greater than 1, then the associated Dehn twists generate a free group of rank 2 in Mod(S). It also proves some fundamental facts about Dehn twists and describes the center of the mapping class group, along with algebraic relations that can occur between two Dehn twists. Finally, it explores three geometric operations on a surface that each induces an algebraic operation on the corresponding mapping class group: the inclusion homomorphism, the capping homomorphism, and the cutting homomorphism.

Right-angled Artin groups and their subgroups are of great interest because of their geometric, combinatorial and algorithmic properties. It is convenient to define these groups using finite simplicial graphs. The isomorphism type of the group is uniquely determined by the graph. Moreover, many structural properties of right-angled Artin groups can be expressed in terms of their defining graph. In this paper, we address the question of understanding the structure of a class of subgroups of right-angled Artin groups in terms of the graph. Bestvina and Brady, in their seminal work, studied these subgroups (now called Bestvina–Brady groups or Artin kernels) from a finiteness conditions viewpoint. Unlike the right-angled Artin groups the isomorphism type of Bestvina–Brady groups is not uniquely determined by the defining graph. We prove that certain finitely presented Bestvina–Brady groups can be expressed as an iterated amalgamated product. Moreover, we show that this amalgamated product can be read off from the graph defining the ambient right-angled Artin group.

We survey embeddability results related to RAAGs (right-angled Artin groups) and various automorphism groups of manifolds. We give two different methods of embedding a RAAG to into another, and deduce that every RAAG embeds into some braid groups. This gives the unsolvability of the isomorphism problem for finitely presented subgroups of braid groups. Also, we prove that every RAAG is a quasi-isometrically embedded subgroup of the symplectomorphism groups of the disk and the sphere, given with suitable $L^p$ metrics. Finally, we embed RAAGs in the smooth diffeomorphism group of the real line. These results reveal many closed hyperbolic manifold subgroups of diffeomorphism groups of manifolds.

Let $S$ be an orientable, connected surface with infinitely-generated fundamental group. The main theorem states that if the genus of $S$ is finite and at least 4, then the isomorphism type of the pure mapping class group associated to $S$, denoted $\mathrm{PMap}(S)$, detects the homeomorphism type of $S$. As a corollary, every automorphism of $\mathrm{PMap}(S)$ is induced by a homeomorphism, which extends a theorem of Ivanov from the finite-type setting. In the process of proving these results, we show that $\mathrm{PMap}(S)$ is residually finite if and only if $S$ has finite genus, demonstrating that the algebraic structure of $\mathrm{PMap}(S)$ can distinguish finite- and infinite-genus surfaces. As an independent result, we also show that $\mathrm{Map}(S)$ fails to be residually finite for any infinite-type surface $S$. In addition, we give a topological generating set for $\mathrm{PMap}(S)$ equipped with the compact-open topology. In particular, if $S$ has at most one end accumulated by genus, then $\mathrm{PMap}(S)$ is topologically generated by Dehn twists, otherwise the Dehn twists along with handle shifts topologically generate.

We show that given a collection \(X=\{f_1\), ..., \(f_m\}\) of pure mapping classes on a surface S, there is an explicit constant N, depending only on X, such that their Nth powers \(\{f_1^N\), ..., \(f_m^N\}\) generate the expected right-angled Artin subgroup of MCG(S). Moreover, we show that these subgroups are undistorted, and that each element is pseudo-Anosov on the largest possible subsurface.

The study of the mapping class group Mod( S ) is a classical topic that is experiencing a renaissance. It lies at the juncture of geometry, topology, and group theory. This book explains as many important theorems, examples, and techniques as possible, quickly and directly, while at the same time giving full details and keeping the text nearly self-contained. The book is suitable for graduate students. A Primer on Mapping Class Groups begins by explaining the main group-theoretical properties of Mod( S ), from finite generation by Dehn twists and low-dimensional homology to the Dehn-Nielsen-Baer theorem. Along the way, central objects and tools are introduced, such as the Birman exact sequence, the complex of curves, the braid group, the symplectic representation, and the Torelli group. The book then introduces Teichmüller space and its geometry, and uses the action of Mod( S ) on it to prove the Nielsen-Thurston classification of surface homeomorphisms. Topics include the topology of the moduli space of Riemann surfaces, the connection with surface bundles, pseudo-Anosov theory, and Thurston's approach to the classification.

Algorithms detecting stability and Morseness for finitely generated groups

Let Mod(Sg) be the mapping class group of an orientable surface of genus g, Sg. The action of Mod(Sg) on the homology of Sg induces the well-known symplectic representation: Mod(Sg) ---> Sp(2g, Z). The kernel of this representation is called the Torelli group, I(Sg). We will study two subgroups of I(Sg). First we will look at the subgroup generated by all SIP-maps, SIP(Sg). We will show SIP(Sg) is not I(Sg) and is in fact an infinite index subgroup of I(Sg). We will also classify which SIP-maps are in the kernel of the Johnson homomorphism and Birman-Craggs-Johnson homomorphism. Then we will look at the symmetric Torelli group, SI(Sg). More specifically, we will investigate the group generated by Dehn twists about symmetric separating curves denoted H(Sg). We will show the well-known Birman-Craggs-Johnson homomorphism is not able to distinguish among SI(Sg), H(Sg), or K(Sg), where K(Sg) is the subgroup generated by Dehn twists about separating curves. Elements of H(Sg) act naturally on the symmetric separating curve complex, CH(S). We will show that when g > 4 Aut(CH(Sg)) = SMod^{+/-}(Sg) / < i > where SMod(Sg) is the symmetric mapping class group and i is a fixed hyperelliptic involution. Lastly we will give an algebraic characterization of Dehn twists about symmetric separating curves.

We calculate the Dehn twist action on the spaces of conformal blocks of a not necessarily semisimple modular category. In particular, we give the order of the Dehn twists under the mapping class group representations of closed surfaces. For Dehn twists about non‐separating simple closed curves, we prove that this order is the order of the ribbon twist, thereby generalizing a result that De Renzi–Gainutdinov–Geer–Patureau–Mirand–Runkel obtained for the small quantum group. In the separating case, we express the order using the order of the ribbon twist on monoidal powers of the canonical end. As an application, we prove that the Johnson kernels of the mapping class groups act trivially if and only if for the canonical end the ribbon twist and double braiding with itself are trivial. We give a similar result for the visibility of the Torelli groups.