<scp> <i>Homo sapiens</i> </scp> —The Perhaps Smartest and Dumbest Animal on Earth?
Animal cognition is concerned with the mental capacities of non-human animals. For many years cognition research has continued to be a thriving field of animal behaviour. The interest in this topic seems unabated, as the recent Behaviour conference—held in Kolkata in August 2025—has shown, with a total of six symposia on animal cognition. At times, I could get the impression of attending a cognition conference rather than a general one on animal behaviour. Unsurprisingly, most of the current studies demonstrate that cognition and intelligence comprise a spectrum rather than a sharp divide between humans and other animals. Even invertebrates such as insects with relatively small brains show surprising mental capabilities, thereby challenging the myth of human exceptionalism. A few years ago, I asked Redouan Bshary, who studies cognition mostly in fish, what he considers special about humans. His slightly disappointing answer was that humans may be the only species that uses contraceptives to prevent reproduction. I expected a more sophisticated response from someone working in the field, but—admittedly—the use of contraceptives certainly requires advanced cognitive abilities. But is contraception really exceptional for humans? Many social insects and even mammals are capable of suppressing the reproduction of other group members, female birds can eject unwanted sperm, rodents can abort embryos, etc. Again, there seems to be some sort of continuum with regard to human exceptionalism, and I would not be surprised to learn if some animals may have discovered medical plants that prevent reproduction. So, what else could make us humans special and distinguish us from other species on Earth? Maybe we are the first species to cause a mass extinction of species on Earth? This may not be a very flattering distinction, but it could set us really apart from all other creatures. So far, there have been five big mass extinctions caused by rapid and dramatic changes in climate. Three of these mass extinctions likely occurred due to tectonic and volcanic activities of our planet—so we can blame Gaia. The most famous mass extinction, the one that killed off most of the dinosaurs, was likely caused by the impact of an asteroid—so we can blame the Universe. However, one mass extinction in the late Devonian about 360 million years ago seems to have been caused by organisms. The rapid growth and diversification of land plants may have led to a rapid cooling of the climate, thereby causing the extinction of a large proportion of species on Earth (Barnosky et al. 2011). And even earlier, about 2.7 billion years ago, the first oxygenic photosynthesizers produced a toxic poison that probably killed off most of the species that relied on an oxygen-free Archaean world (Lenton and Watson 2011). There goes human exceptionalism—once again. But—and here cognition comes into play again—for sure we are the first organism with a brain and the cognitive abilities that may cause a mass extinction knowingly with eyes wide open. And this extinction could possibly include ourselves—very unlike the oxygenic photosynthesizers which were smart enough to dominate the planet ever since they came into existence billions of years ago. So, in terms of cognitive abilities perhaps we are both the smartest and the dumbest creature planet Earth has ever seen! I could end here, but maybe science offers some hope. In his autobiography, Max Planck—one of the most famous physicists—formulated the Planck principle, stating “An important scientific innovation rarely makes its way by gradually winning over and converting its opponents: it rarely happens that Saul becomes Paul. What does happen is that its opponents gradually die out, and that the growing generation is familiarized with the ideas from the beginning: another instance of the fact that the future lies with the youth” (Planck 1949). Planck's principle seems to hold for science (Azoulay et al. 2019), and if it can be applied to world politics there may be some hope. Most of the world leaders responsible for the detrimental path of the planet in terms of preventing or solving the climate crisis and biodiversity loss are beyond their 70s. And some of their super-rich supporters plan to escape to Mars. Let's hope they do so, soon! So perhaps there is a chance that the smartest and the dumbest of all creatures on Earth may use some of its (younger) brains to work for the better. Imagine, all the billions of Dollars, Euros, Roubles, and Renminbis that are currently spent on producing arms and weapons could be spent on solving the climate and biodiversity crisis, instead. All of humanity's major problems would be solved in no time—what a no-brainer! The author declares no conflicts of interest. The author has nothing to report.
Read more