Efficient and optimal scheduling of time-constrained hybrid multi-cluster tools in semiconductor industry

A treelike hybrid multi-cluster tool is composed of both single-arm and dual-arm cluster tools with a treelike topology. Scheduling such a tool is challenging. For a hybrid treelike multi-cluster tool whose bottleneck individual tool is process-bound, this work aims at finding its optimal one-wafer cyclic schedule. It is modeled with Petri nets such that a onewafer cyclic schedule is parameterized as its robots’ waiting time. Based on the model, this work proves the existence of its onewafer cyclic schedule that features with the ease of industrial implementation. Then, computationally efficient algorithms are proposed to find the minimal cycle time and optimal onewafer cyclic schedule. Multi-cluster tool examples are given to illustrate the proposed approach. The use of the found schedules enables industrial multi-cluster tools to operate with their highest productivity.

Scheduling a cluster tool with wafer residency time constraints is challenging and important in wafer manufacturing. With a backward strategy, the scheduling problem of such singlerobot-arm cluster tools is well-studied in the literature. It is much more challenging to schedule a more general case whose optimal scheduling strategy is not limited to the backward one. This work uses a timed Petri net (PN) to model the dynamic behavior of the system and presents a method to determine the optimal scheduling strategy for the system. Based on its PN model and the obtained strategy, it reveals that the key issue to schedule such a tool is to determine when and how long the robot should wait for. Based on this finding, this work establishes for the first time the necessary and sufficient conditions regarding the existence of an optimal and feasible one-wafer cyclic schedule for singlerobot-arm cluster tools. It then formulates a computationally efficient linear program to find it if existing, and finally gives industrial examples to show the application and power of the proposed method.

A multi-cluster tool is composed of a number of individual cluster tools linked by buffering modules (BMs). The capacity of a BM can be one or two. Aiming at finding an optimal one-wafer cyclic schedule, this paper explores the effect of two-space BMs on the performance of a multi-cluster tool. A Petri net (PN) model is developed to model it by extending resource-oriented PNs. The dynamic behavior of robot waiting and tasks, process modules, and buffers is well described by the model. This paper shows that there is always a one-wafer cyclic schedule that reaches the lower bound of the cycle time of a process-bound tool. Furthermore, a closed-form algorithm is revealed to find such a schedule for the first time for such multi-cluster tools. Illustrative examples are given to show the application and power of the proposed method.

In semiconductor manufacturing, wafer residency time constraints make the scheduling problem of cluster tools complicated. A process module (PM) in cluster tools is prone to failure. It is crucial to deal with any such failure in a proper and timely manner. If there are feasible periodic schedules in operating a cluster tool before and after a PM failure, it is desired to make it operate continuously when such a failure occurs. However, due to wafer residency time constraints, it is highly challenging to control a tool such that it can be correctly transferred from a feasible schedule before failure to another after it. To solve this problem, a Petri net model is developed to describe the dynamic behavior of a single-arm cluster tool and failure response policies are proposed. The proposed policies are formulated via simple control laws for their easy implementation. Examples are given to show them.

In semiconductor manufacturing systems, a time-constrained multi-cluster tool should be scheduled such that a wafer stays in a process chamber in a given time range to satisfy a wafer residency time constraint. In practice, activity time is subject to variation. It could lead to some fluctuation of wafer residency time in a process chamber. Hence, it is crucial to analyze how wafer residency time varies with activity time variation. This issue is especially challenging for multi-cluster tools. This work focuses on determining the exact upper bound of wafer sojourn time delay resulted from activity time variation for dual-arm multi-cluster tools. After discussing their dynamic behaviours, it presents a two-level real-time operational architecture and a real-time control policy. Based on them, this work derives for the first time an efficient algorithm to calculate the exact upper bound of wafer sojourn time delay in a process chamber. As a result, engineers can test whether a given schedule is feasible. Several examples of industrial significance are used to demonstrate the application of the proposed approach.

In semiconductor manufacturing, a process module (PM) failure in cluster tools (CTs) happens from time to time. To effectively operate a CT, such a failure should be handled in a proper and timely manner. This issue becomes much more complicated because wafer residency time constraints (WRTCs) must be met to ensure the quality for some wafer fabrication processes. With such constraints, if a tool is operated under a periodic schedule and a PM fails, it is desired that the tool can still operate under a periodic schedule if it is possible. Nevertheless, the periodic schedule after a PM failure must be different from that before its failure since in this case the tool is degraded. Thus, there must be a transient process between them. It is a great challenge to operate a tool such that it can go through such a transient process with WRTCs being always satisfied. This paper aims to solve this problem by proposing PM failure response policies which can successfully transfer a CT to the feasible schedule after failure from the one before a failure. Then, efficient algorithms are developed to improve these response policies. The proposed policies are composed of simple control laws such that they can be realized in real time and online. Illustrative examples are presented to show their applications.

Scheduling of time-constrained single-arm cluster tools with purge operations in wafer fabrications

With the requirements of physical vapor deposition and chemical vapor deposition processes, twin-cluster tools are widely used in the current wafer fabrication. Cycle scheduling ensures that wafers have the same quality, however, twin-cluster tools involve resource coordination between two tools, which makes cycle scheduling more sophisticated. A steady-state cycle scheduling problem of twin-cluster tools with a complete concurrent processing module is studied, considering the wafer residency time constraints. First, a Petri net model is constructed to describe the process of twin-cluster tools under a steady state with the wafer residency time constraints and the complete concurrent processing module, and a control strategy is proposed to avoid the system deadlock. The sufficient conditions for the system to reach the highest efficiency are obtained by analyzing the workload of the processing module and the robot task, and an algorithm is developed to obtain the robot schedule. Finally, examples are verified about the effectiveness of the algorithms.

Bayesian Belief Network-based approach for diagnostics and prognostics of semiconductor manufacturing systems

It is a great challenge to find an optimal one-wafer cyclic schedule for a single-arm multicluster tool that is widely adopted in semiconductor fabrication. Aiming to tackle this significant problem, an optimal scheduling strategy is determined first for each individual tool under the condition that the bottleneck individual tool is transport-bound. Then, by developing a Petri net model with robot waiting being explicitly described to reveal the properties of the entire system, this paper shows that to schedule such a tool optimally is to allocate the robot waiting time properly. Then, this paper presents the necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of an optimal one-wafer cyclic schedule. Thereafter, an efficient algorithm is developed to check the given conditions and find such a schedule efficiently if existing. Finally, two industrial examples are used to verify that the proposed method is applicable and effective.

Green scheduling of dual-armed cluster tool based on cleaning scenarios

Scheduling of multicluster tools has received much attention due to its complexity of interaction among cluster tools. A cluster tool comprises several modules such as processing modules, a transfer module with a single or dual-armed handling robot, and loadlock modules. A multicluster tool comprises two, three, or more cluster tools that are interconnected with each other. In this paper, we propose a deadlock prevention policy for noncyclic scheduling of dual-armed multicluster tools. The proposed deadlock prevention policy is effective for generating an efficient schedule for two or three-connected multicluster tools with a single or a dual-path flow. This is proven by analyzing the strict minimal siphon of the Petri net model. The performance of the proposed method is compared with that of a maximal permissible deadlock prevention policy. The results demonstrate that the proposed method is computationally efficient for larger state spaces and more suitable than conventional deadlock prevention policies for generating effective schedules for noncyclic scheduling of multicluster tools. Note to Practitioners —Scheduling of multicluster tools has recently attracted attention in the growing semiconductor manufacturing industry. Most conventional studies on multicluster tools focus on cyclic scheduling to minimize cycle time with swap strategy. The challenge addressed by this paper is to derive a deadlock-free schedule for multicluster tools with noncyclic operations. We propose a simple deadlock prevention policy that can be applied to large-scale timed Petri net (PN) model of general multicluster tools without enumeration of siphon computations or solution of mixed integer programming. A timed PN model is developed for noncyclic operations of dual-armed multicluster tools with a dual ath. The computational results show that the approximately 10% of the total throughput of the proposed method is better than those of the conventional methods. It enables more efficient operations for noncyclic scheduling under transient periods including cleaning operations.

The main challenge in scheduling multi-cluster tools in semiconductor manufacturing is the interactions among clusters. These interactions create a k-unit optimal production that do not exist in single-cluster tools. This paper analyzes optimal scheduling of k-unit cycle production of multi-cluster tools with single-blade robots. A resource-based method is used to analytically derive closed-form expressions for the minimal cycle time of a multi-cluster tool. Conditions for decoupling multi-cluster tools and optimality conditions for the widely used pull schedule are also presented. An example from industry production is used to illustrate the derived formula and decoupling conditions.

Two-stage heuristic procedure for scheduling job shops

Capacity planning for cluster tools in the semiconductor industry